Abdomino-Thoracic Breathing Pattern Causes
An abdomino-thoracic breathing pattern—where thoracic (rib cage) breathing predominates over abdominal (diaphragmatic) breathing—is caused by conditions that impair diaphragmatic function, restrict abdominal movement, or increase respiratory muscle work.
Primary Causes
Neuromuscular Disorders
Neuromuscular diseases directly impair diaphragmatic function, forcing compensatory thoracic breathing. Patients with spinal muscular atrophy and myopathies demonstrate marked abnormalities in thoracoabdominal breathing patterns during spontaneous breathing, with severely reduced diaphragmatic contribution 1. This represents ineffective diaphragmatic function requiring the respiratory system to rely predominantly on intercostal and accessory muscles.
Severe COPD and Respiratory Failure
In chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, particularly in severely disabled patients, the diaphragm may paradoxically move upward during inspiration rather than downward. Five of 20 ambulatory COPD patients and 8 of 10 patients in acute respiratory failure showed inward abdominal motion coincident with outward rib cage motion during inspiration, indicating ineffective diaphragmatic function 2. This pattern is identical to that seen in quadriplegics with complete diaphragmatic paralysis, confirming that the thoracic muscles are compensating for diaphragmatic failure.
Post-Surgical States
Abdominal Surgery
After both emergency and elective abdominal surgery, the operation restricts abdominal-diaphragmatic breathing movement, reflected as increased rib cage contribution to tidal volume (from 37% to 57% in elective upper abdominal surgery, p<0.001) 3. The surgical trauma and pain inhibit diaphragmatic excursion, forcing a shift to thoracic breathing.
Cardiac Surgery via Sternotomy
Following median sternotomy, the breathing pattern shifts from predominantly abdominal to thoracic and upper thoracic, with average abdominal motion decreasing to 57% of preoperative values bilaterally, while right upper thoracic motion actually increases 3% 4. This shift is associated with reduced pulmonary function (lung volumes decrease to around 60% of preoperative values) and represents a less effective breathing pattern.
Visceral Afferent Stimulation
Activation of visceral afferents from the mesenteric region reflexly changes diaphragmatic breathing to intercostal breathing 5. This occurs through:
- Mechanical distension of the small intestine
- Stimulation of mesenteric nerves causing depression of phrenic nerve activity
- Simultaneous excitation of external intercostal muscle activity
This mechanism explains the thoracic breathing pattern in:
- Pregnancy (uterine distension)
- Abdominal distension from any cause
- Pathophysiological situations involving splanchnic viscera
Clinical Algorithm for Identifying the Cause
When encountering a patient with predominant thoracic breathing:
Assess for neuromuscular disease: Look for generalized weakness, muscle atrophy, or known diagnoses of spinal muscular atrophy, muscular dystrophy, or myopathy
Evaluate respiratory disease severity: In COPD patients, check for severe disability, very large residual volumes, and fluoroscopic evidence of paradoxical diaphragmatic movement
Consider recent surgery: Post-operative patients within 1-2 weeks of abdominal or thoracic surgery will demonstrate this pattern
Examine for abdominal pathology: Distension, pregnancy, ascites, or acute intra-abdominal processes that stimulate visceral afferents
Assess respiratory muscle fatigue: Patients in acute respiratory failure of any etiology may shift to thoracic breathing as diaphragmatic fatigue develops
Critical Pitfalls
Do not assume thoracic breathing is benign: It represents a less efficient breathing pattern associated with reduced pulmonary function and increased work of breathing 4
Recognize this as a sign of respiratory muscle dysfunction: The pattern often indicates diaphragmatic failure or severe impairment, particularly when inward abdominal motion occurs during inspiration 2
Post-operative patients require intervention: The shift to upper thoracic breathing after surgery is associated with worse outcomes, and therapeutic interventions aimed at correcting this pattern should be implemented 4