Approach to Lower Back Pain: HPI, Differential Diagnosis, and Physical Examination
Your primary goal is to categorize the patient into one of three diagnostic buckets through focused history and exam: (1) nonspecific low back pain (85-95% of cases), (2) radiculopathy or spinal stenosis (5-10%), or (3) serious underlying pathology (<1%). 1
History of Present Illness (HPI) Documentation
Essential Elements to Document:
Pain Characteristics:
- Duration: Acute (<4 weeks), subacute (4-12 weeks), or chronic (>3 months) 1
- Location: Localized to back versus radiating below the knee (sciatica suggests radiculopathy) 1
- Quality and severity: Use validated pain scales
- Aggravating/relieving factors: Pain with walking/standing relieved by sitting suggests neurogenic claudication 1
Red Flag Symptoms (indicating serious pathology):
- Age >50 or <20 years
- History of cancer
- Unexplained weight loss
- Fever, chills, or recent infection
- Immunosuppression or IV drug use
- Severe trauma
- Urinary retention or fecal incontinence (cauda equina syndrome) 1
- Saddle anesthesia
- Bilateral lower extremity weakness
- Progressive neurologic deficits
- Failure to improve after 4-6 weeks of conservative therapy
Psychosocial Risk Factors (predict chronic disability):
- Depression or anxiety
- Job dissatisfaction
- Pending litigation or disability claims
- Catastrophizing or fear-avoidance behaviors 1
Differential Diagnosis Framework
Category 1: Nonspecific Low Back Pain (85-95%)
Pain primarily in the back without red flags, no radicular symptoms, and no specific identifiable cause. Degenerative changes on imaging correlate poorly with symptoms and should be considered nonspecific 1. This is a diagnosis of exclusion.
Category 2: Radiculopathy or Spinal Stenosis (5-10%)
Radiculopathy/Sciatica:
- Pain radiating below the knee in sciatic nerve distribution
- Sensory impairment, weakness, or diminished reflexes in nerve root distribution 1
Spinal Stenosis:
- Neurogenic claudication: leg pain/weakness with walking or standing
- Relief with sitting or spinal flexion 1
Category 3: Serious Specific Pathology (<1%)
By prevalence:
- Vertebral compression fracture (4%)
- Cancer (0.7%)
- Spinal infection (0.01%)
- Cauda equina syndrome (rare emergency)
- Ankylosing spondylitis
- Referred pain from abdominal/pelvic pathology 1
Focused Physical Examination
Neurological Examination (Critical for radiculopathy):
Straight Leg Raise Test:
- Flex hip with knee extended
- Positive: Reproduction of sciatica at 30-70 degrees elevation
- Crossed straight leg raise (contralateral leg elevation reproduces symptoms): highly specific for nerve root compression 1
Motor Testing (by nerve root):
- L4: Ankle dorsiflexion
- L5: Great toe extension
- S1: Ankle plantarflexion
Sensory Testing:
- L4: Medial foot
- L5: Dorsal foot/first web space
- S1: Lateral foot
Reflexes:
- Patellar (L4)
- Achilles (S1)
Inspection and Palpation:
- Observe gait and posture
- Palpate for focal tenderness, step-offs, or masses
- Assess range of motion (flexion, extension, lateral bending)
Red Flag Examination Findings:
- Saddle anesthesia (perianal sensation)
- Rectal tone assessment if cauda equina suspected
- Fever or focal spine tenderness (infection)
- Abdominal/pelvic exam if referred pain suspected
Imaging Decision Algorithm
Do NOT image routinely for nonspecific low back pain 1. This exposes patients to unnecessary radiation and identifies abnormalities that correlate poorly with symptoms, potentially leading to harmful interventions.
Image immediately (MRI preferred, or CT) when:
- Severe or progressive neurologic deficits present
- Cauda equina syndrome suspected
- Signs of infection (fever, focal tenderness, immunosuppression)
- History of cancer with new back pain
- Significant trauma 1
Consider delayed imaging (plain radiographs initially) for:
- Osteoporosis or chronic steroid use (compression fracture risk)
- Age >50 with risk factors for cancer
- Persistent symptoms >4-6 weeks despite conservative therapy 1
MRI or CT only for radiculopathy/stenosis if:
- Symptoms persist despite 4 weeks of conservative care AND
- Patient is a candidate for surgery or epidural steroid injection 1
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Over-imaging nonspecific low back pain: This leads to identification of incidental findings, patient anxiety, and cascade of unnecessary interventions 1
Missing cauda equina syndrome: Always ask about urinary retention, fecal incontinence, and saddle anesthesia. This is a surgical emergency with poor outcomes if delayed 1
Ignoring psychosocial factors: These are the strongest predictors of chronic disability and must be documented and addressed 1
Labeling patients with specific anatomical diagnoses without validation: Terms like "disc bulge" or "facet arthropathy" based on imaging alone are not validated and may harm patients by creating fear-avoidance 1
Ordering ESR/CRP routinely: Reserve for suspected infection or malignancy. ESR ≥20 mm/h has 78% sensitivity and 67% specificity for cancer 1