I:E Ratio in ARDS
The major ARDS guidelines do not specify a particular I:E ratio as a standard recommendation, but conventional ratios (1:2 to 1:1) are typically used, with inverse ratio ventilation (I:E > 1:1) NOT routinely recommended despite historical interest.
What the Guidelines Actually Say
The most authoritative guidelines on ARDS ventilation—the 2017 ATS/ESICM/SCCM guidelines 1111 and the 2016 Surviving Sepsis Campaign guidelines 2333—focus their strong recommendations on:
- Tidal volume: 4-8 mL/kg predicted body weight (strong recommendation)
- Plateau pressure: < 30 cm H₂O (strong recommendation)
- PEEP: Higher PEEP for moderate-severe ARDS (conditional recommendation)
- Prone positioning: > 12 hours/day for severe ARDS with PaO₂/FiO₂ < 150 (strong recommendation)
Notably absent from these guidelines is any specific recommendation about I:E ratio. This omission is deliberate and evidence-based.
The BTS/ICS Guidance on I:E Ratios
The 2016 BTS/ICS guideline for ventilatory management 4 provides the most explicit guidance on I:E ratios, though for hypercapnic respiratory failure rather than ARDS specifically:
- Obstructive disease: I:E ratio of 1:2 to 1:4 (prolonged expiratory time to prevent gas trapping)
- Neuromuscular disease/chest wall deformity: I:E ratio of 1:1 to 1:2
For ARDS specifically, they note that prolonging expiratory time limits gas trapping and recommend shortening inspiratory time in obstructive conditions.
Why Inverse Ratio Ventilation Is Not Recommended
Despite early enthusiasm, research has consistently failed to demonstrate benefit from inverse ratio ventilation (IRV) in ARDS:
The evidence against routine IRV:
A controlled study comparing IRV (I:E = 2:1) to conventional ventilation (I:E = 0.5:1) found that IRV decreased cardiac output and oxygen delivery without improving oxygenation when tidal volume and total PEEP were kept constant 5
Another study comparing PC-IRV ratios of 1:1,2:1, and 4:1 versus conventional PCV 1:2 found that IRV decreased arterial and mixed venous oxygenation without improving gastric mucosal perfusion when mean airway pressure was held constant 6
A 1994 study found no short-term beneficial effect of pressure-controlled IRV over conventional volume-controlled ventilation with PEEP 7
Practical Approach to I:E Ratio in ARDS
Use conventional I:E ratios (1:2 to 1:1) as your default approach. The focus should be on:
- Achieving lung-protective ventilation parameters (low tidal volume, plateau pressure < 30 cm H₂O)
- Optimizing PEEP for moderate-severe ARDS
- Implementing prone positioning for severe ARDS (PaO₂/FiO₂ < 150)
- Allowing adequate expiratory time to prevent auto-PEEP and gas trapping
When to Consider Adjusting I:E Ratio:
- Shorten inspiratory time (increase expiratory time) if you detect significant auto-PEEP or gas trapping
- Maintain I:E around 1:1 to 1:2 for most ARDS patients
- Avoid inverse ratios unless in exceptional circumstances with refractory hypoxemia and expert consultation, recognizing the potential for hemodynamic compromise
Key Pitfalls to Avoid
- Don't chase inverse ratios thinking they'll improve oxygenation—the evidence shows they don't, and they may harm hemodynamics 56
- Don't confuse mean airway pressure increases from IRV with beneficial recruitment—when controlled for total PEEP and mean airway pressure, IRV offers no advantage 6
- Monitor for auto-PEEP development, which can occur with any I:E ratio but is more likely with shorter expiratory times
- Remember that hemodynamic compromise from increased intrathoracic pressure can offset any theoretical oxygenation benefits
The 2024 ATS update 8 and 2023 ESICM guidelines 9 continue to emphasize the core lung-protective strategies without advocating for specific I:E ratio manipulation, reinforcing that I:E ratio is not a primary therapeutic target in ARDS management.