Ochsner-Sherren Regimen and Mantrel Score
The Ochsner-Sherren regimen is a conservative, non-operative approach for treating appendiceal mass/phlegmon consisting of bowel rest, IV fluids, IV antibiotics, and close observation, though this historical regimen is not mentioned in current evidence-based guidelines which now favor either immediate appendectomy or interval appendectomy after initial antibiotic treatment.
Clarification on the "Mantrel Score"
The term "Mantrel score" appears to be a misspelling or confusion with existing appendicitis scoring systems. Based on the evidence provided, there is no validated scoring system called the "Mantrel score" in the medical literature for acute appendicitis. You likely mean one of the following validated scores:
Alvarado Score (Modified Alvarado/MANTRELS)
- Sensitivity: 99% (at cutoff <5 for excluding appendicitis)
- Specificity: Not sufficiently specific for confirming diagnosis in adults 1
- The acronym MANTRELS represents the components: Migration of pain, Anorexia, Nausea/vomiting, Tenderness in RLQ, Rebound pain, Elevated temperature, Leukocytosis, Shift to left
However, current guidelines recommend AGAINST using the Alvarado score alone to confirm appendicitis in adults 1. The Alvarado score is unreliable in differentiating complicated from uncomplicated appendicitis in elderly patients and less sensitive in HIV+ patients 1.
Recommended Scoring Systems (2020 WSES Guidelines)
The AIR (Appendicitis Inflammatory Response) score and AAS (Adult Appendicitis Score) are currently the best-performing clinical prediction scores 1:
- AIR Score Performance:
Clinical Application Algorithm:
- Low-risk patients (AIR <5): Can avoid imaging and admission, observe outpatient
- Intermediate-risk patients (AIR 5-8): Proceed with imaging (US first, then CT/MRI if needed) 1
- High-risk patients (AIR 9-12, age <40): May proceed directly to surgery without CT 1
Ochsner-Sherren Regimen Context
While the Ochsner-Sherren regimen is a historical conservative management approach for appendiceal mass, modern guidelines do not specifically endorse this named regimen. Instead, current evidence supports:
For Appendiceal Mass/Phlegmon:
- Initial conservative management with IV antibiotics is acceptable
- Source control (percutaneous drainage) if abscess present
- Postoperative antibiotics should NOT be prolonged beyond 3-5 days if adequate source control achieved [QoE: High; Strength: Strong; 1A] 1
Key Pitfalls to Avoid:
- Do not rely on Alvarado score alone to confirm appendicitis diagnosis 1
- Do not use clinical scores alone in pediatric patients 1
- Always combine clinical scores with imaging (US first-line) for intermediate-risk patients 1
- In pregnant patients, never diagnose on symptoms/signs alone—always obtain labs and imaging (US first, then MRI if equivocal) 1, 2