Evans Criteria for Growing Pains
The Evans criteria are a set of clinical diagnostic criteria used to identify growing pains in children, consisting of three essential features: (1) bilateral leg pain, (2) pain occurring in the late afternoon or evening/night, and (3) absence of objective clinical findings such as limp, limitation of activity, or abnormal physical examination.
Core Diagnostic Components
The Evans criteria establish a clinical diagnosis based on:
- Bilateral lower extremity pain (though recent evidence suggests unilateral pain should also be considered valid) 1
- Timing: Pain predominantly occurs in late afternoon, evening, or nighttime hours
- Normal physical examination: No swelling, erythema, warmth, or joint abnormalities
- No functional impairment: Child does not limp and maintains normal activity levels during the day
- Intermittent pattern: Pain is recurrent rather than constant
Important Clinical Nuances
Age Range
Growing pains typically affect children aged 3-12 years, with prevalence increasing with age. In a Danish cohort, prevalence ranged from 24-43% depending on the specific definition used 1.
Pain Characteristics to Assess
- Location: Most commonly lower legs (89.7% in lower extremities), though can occur in thighs 2
- Laterality: Bilateral in 86.2% of cases, though unilateral presentation occurs and should not exclude diagnosis 2
- Nocturnal awakening: Occurs in approximately 60.8% of patients 2
- Frequency: Typically 1-3 times per week 1
Critical Red Flags (Exclusion Criteria)
These features suggest alternative diagnoses and warrant further investigation:
- History of arthritis or trauma
- Morning stiffness
- Persistent limping
- Limitation of activities during daytime
- School absenteeism due to pain
- Abnormal physical examination findings
All of these were significantly more prevalent in diseased controls than in growing pain patients 2.
Practical Application Algorithm
Step 1: Verify bilateral leg pain (or unilateral, per modified criteria 1)
Step 2: Confirm timing pattern (late afternoon/evening/nighttime)
Step 3: Perform thorough physical examination - must be completely normal
Step 4: Assess for red flags listed above - if present, pursue alternative diagnosis
Step 5: Confirm no functional impairment during daytime activities
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
The term "growing pains" is a misnomer: No significant association exists between these pains and periods of rapid growth 1, 3. The name persists historically but is not pathophysiologically accurate.
Don't exclude unilateral pain: While Evans' original criteria emphasized bilateral pain, recent evidence supports including unilateral presentations 1.
Laboratory testing is generally unnecessary: When performed, elevated alkaline phosphatase (37.5%) and lactate dehydrogenase (15.6%) may be observed but are not diagnostic 3. These should not be routinely ordered for diagnosis.
Consider migraine association: Growing pains may represent a precursor or comorbidity with migraine, particularly in children with maternal migraine history. In one cohort, 76% of children with growing pains developed migraine over 5 years versus 22% of controls 4.
Modified Criteria Recommendation
The most current evidence suggests using Evans' criteria with the addition of accepting unilateral pain as a valid presentation 1. This modification improves diagnostic sensitivity without compromising specificity, as demonstrated in the largest cohort studies using machine learning validation 2.