Treatment for Ureteric Stones by Size Range
For ureteral stones, treatment selection depends critically on stone size and location: stones <5mm can be observed with medical expulsive therapy (MET), stones 5-10mm should be treated with ureteroscopy (URS) or shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) with URS preferred for distal stones, stones 10-20mm require URS as first-line treatment, and stones >20mm necessitate percutaneous antegrade approach. 1, 2
Stones <5mm: Conservative Management
Observation with MET is the appropriate initial approach for stones under 5mm, as spontaneous passage occurs in approximately 75% of cases 1. The passage rate varies by location:
- Distal ureter: 89% for stones <5mm
- Upper ureter: 75% for stones <5mm
- Mid ureter: 58-70%
Stone passage typically occurs within 17 days (range 6-29 days) 1. MET should be discontinued if complications develop including infection, refractory pain, or declining renal function 1.
Stones 5-10mm: Surgical Intervention Required
Distal Ureteral Stones ≤10mm
Both URS and SWL are acceptable options, but URS demonstrates superior stone-free rates 2. Contemporary evidence shows URS achieves higher single-procedure success rates compared to SWL for distal stones 2, 3.
Key decision factors:
- URS provides higher stone-free rates but requires anesthesia and possible stenting
- SWL is less invasive but has lower success rates and higher retreatment rates
- Retreatment rates are significantly lower with URS (p<0.01) 3
Proximal Ureteral Stones <20mm
For stones <10mm, either URS or SWL may be offered 2. However, meta-analysis demonstrates URS achieves higher stone-free rates in a single procedure compared to SWL for proximal stones 2.
For stones 10-20mm in the proximal ureter, URS should be the preferred first-line treatment 2, 4. The evidence shows:
- URS effectiveness is superior to SWL for stones >10mm 5, 4
- Stone-free rates are significantly higher with URS (p<0.01, OR=0.40) 3
- Retreatment rates are substantially lower with URS 3
Important Caveat for SWL
If SWL is chosen, initiate treatment with low-energy shockwaves and gradually escalate to reduce bleeding complications 2. If no stone fragmentation or clearance occurs after initial SWL, switch to URS 2. After 2 unsuccessful SWL sessions, an alternate modality (URS) must be undertaken 2.
Stones >20mm: Percutaneous Approach
For ureteral stones >20mm, or stones that have failed retrograde URS or SWL, offer a percutaneous antegrade approach 2. These larger stones are not amenable to standard endoscopic techniques and require more invasive intervention.
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not routinely place stents with SWL - both fragmentation and stone-free rates are notably lower with routine stenting 4
Do not persist with failed SWL - if obstruction continues after initial treatment, switch modalities promptly to prevent irreversible renal function loss 2
Do not use stone diameter alone for 10-20mm stones - stone volume >1064mm³ predicts worse RIRS outcomes; consider mini-PCNL for larger volumes 6
Avoid blind basket extraction without fluoroscopic control and guidewires 7
Quality of Life Considerations
URS provides better health-related quality of life than SWL for ureteral stones, while the opposite is true for renal stones 8. MET provides better quality of life than active surveillance alone 8.