Why Pulmonary Regurgitation Murmur Increases with Inspiration
Pulmonary regurgitation murmurs increase in intensity during inspiration because right-sided cardiac murmurs become louder with inspiration due to increased venous return to the right heart. 1
Physiologic Mechanism
During inspiration, negative intrathoracic pressure augments venous return to the right side of the heart. This increased preload to the right ventricle results in:
- Greater right ventricular stroke volume
- Increased blood flow across the pulmonary valve
- Enhanced regurgitant flow back through an incompetent pulmonary valve during diastole
The ACC/AHA valvular heart disease guidelines explicitly state that "right-sided murmurs generally increase with inspiration" while left-sided murmurs are louder during expiration 1. This fundamental principle applies to all right-sided valvular lesions, including pulmonary regurgitation.
Clinical Characteristics of the Pulmonary Regurgitation Murmur
The murmur characteristics depend on whether pulmonary hypertension is present:
With pulmonary hypertension:
- High-pitched, decrescendo early diastolic murmur
- Begins immediately with S2
- Reflects rapid decline in regurgitant volume during diastole 1
Without pulmonary hypertension (isolated PR):
- Low to medium-pitched murmur
- Slightly delayed onset after pulmonic valve closure
- The delay occurs because the reverse pressure gradient is initially minimal 1
- Common after tetralogy of Fallot repair 1
- Described as crescendo-decrescendo, early to mid-diastolic 2
Auscultation Location
The pulmonary regurgitation murmur is best heard at the second and third left intercostal spaces and increases during inspiration, particularly when a hyperdynamic right ventricle is present 2.
Important Clinical Caveat
One study noted an unusual exception: in a patient with concurrent mitral regurgitation, the PR murmur paradoxically decreased with inspiration before mitral valve surgery, then normalized to the expected increase after mitral valve replacement 3. This occurred because inspiration reduced mitral regurgitation volume, which in turn reduced the volume overload and subsequent pulmonary regurgitation. However, this represents a rare exception to the general rule and should not alter standard clinical assessment.
Practical Application
When evaluating a diastolic murmur at the left upper sternal border, have the patient take a deep breath in while you listen—if the murmur becomes louder, this strongly suggests a right-sided origin (pulmonary regurgitation) rather than aortic regurgitation, which would remain unchanged or become softer with inspiration.