Types of Caps for Tracheostomy Capping Trials
Pulmonologists recommend a stepwise progression starting with a one-way speaking valve during wakefulness, followed by standard tracheostomy caps for daytime and eventually 24-hour capping trials, rather than using multiple different cap types. 1
The Recommended Progression
The 2025 American Thoracic Society guidelines outline a clear algorithmic approach to capping trials that prioritizes device type based on the stage of decannulation readiness:
Step 1: Speaking Valve (One-Way Valve)
- Initial device of choice before progressing to full capping 1
- A one-way device placed on the external tracheostomy tube opening that redirects airflow upward through the vocal folds during expiration
- Allows exhalation through the upper airway while preventing inhalation through the trach
- Clinical benefits beyond assessment:
- Improves secretion management
- Aids oral communication
- Augments olfaction (impacts eating)
- May improve swallowing function 1
- Critical indicator: Well-tolerated speaking valve suggests readiness for tracheostomy capping; intolerance should trigger investigation for airway obstruction 1
Step 2: Standard Tracheostomy Cap
- Used after speaking valve tolerance is established 1
- Completely occludes the tracheostomy tube opening
- Initially used during daytime wakefulness
- Progresses to 24-hour capping trials with monitoring (polysomnography or pulse oximetry with/without capnography) 1
What About Fenestrated Tubes?
Fenestrated tracheostomy tubes are NOT standard practice for capping trials in children and should generally be avoided 1. While they theoretically enhance airflow to the upper airway and may promote speech, their use—particularly for extended periods—raises concerns about granulation tissue development around the fenestration. Some centers have explored fenestrated tubes as an alternative to tube downsizing, but this remains non-standard practice.
Critical Caveats
Tube Downsizing Controversy
The evidence is mixed on whether to downsize the tracheostomy tube before capping 1:
- Pro-downsizing: Polysomnograms after downsizing typically show less severe sleep-disordered breathing
- Anti-downsizing: Smaller-diameter tubes may increase mucous plugging risk
- Key finding: Not downsizing was associated with increased chance of unfavorable capped studies, though no clinical disadvantage was found when capped PSGs were favorable
Cuff Management
The cuff must be deflated during capping trials 2, 3. Research demonstrates that:
- Atmospheric pressure or incompletely deflated cuffs create significant tracheal pressure drops (up to 4.2 kPa at high flow rates)
- Complete deflation reduces pressure drop and airway resistance
- Cuff deformation during flow can cause irregular pressures and unsuccessful capping trials due to increased airway resistance
Monitoring During Capping
The guidelines recommend 1:
- Standard approach: Polysomnography OR pulse oximetry (with/without capnography) under direct observation with capped tracheostomy
- Mandatory PSG situations:
- Assessing transition from invasive to noninvasive ventilation
- Unclear cause of failed capping trials
- Patients with medical and/or airway complexity
Alternative Approaches (Not Standard)
While the evidence base includes studies using stoma buttons after decannulation 2, these are placement devices after tube removal rather than capping trial devices. Research shows stoma buttons produce negligible pressure drop (maximum 0.014 kPa) and have no clinically relevant impact on airway resistance.
The key takeaway: There aren't multiple "types" of caps recommended—the approach is sequential device progression (speaking valve → standard cap) rather than choosing between different cap varieties.