Can You Still Hear a Murmur After TAVI for Severe AS?
Yes, you can still hear a murmur after TAVI, and this is extremely common—occurring in the vast majority of patients due to paravalvular regurgitation, which is present in approximately 75% of patients at 1 year. 1
Understanding Post-TAVI Murmurs
The murmur you hear after TAVI is fundamentally different from the pre-procedure stenotic murmur:
What Causes the Post-TAVI Murmur
Paravalvular regurgitation is the primary source, occurring in 85% of patients immediately post-TAVI 1. This happens because:
- Calcific deposits prevent the valve from sealing completely against the annulus
- Eccentric calcification creates gaps between the prosthesis and native tissue
- The prosthesis may be undersized or inadequately expanded
- Heavy irregular calcific deposits in the annular area prevent proper seating 1
Central regurgitation can also occur but is less common, resulting from:
- Improper valve deployment or sizing
- Overhanging leaflet material affecting closure
- Leaflet damage during crimping 1
Clinical Significance by Severity
The degree of regurgitation matters critically for outcomes:
Mild or trace AR: Present in approximately 80% of patients at 1 year—requires no specific therapy beyond standard medical management and periodic echocardiographic monitoring 2
Moderate to severe AR: Present in only 7-12% of patients—this is the critical threshold that impacts mortality 2, 3
Post-TAVI significant aortic regurgitation is the only independent predictor of mortality (hazard ratio 5.592) 3. This underscores why the severity of any murmur you hear must be quantified immediately.
What You Should Do Clinically
Immediate Post-Procedure Assessment
You must characterize any murmur by:
- Location: Central vs. paravalvular
- Severity: Integrate both origins to estimate overall volumetric impact
- Cause: Deployment issue, sizing problem, or calcification 1, 4
Key Pitfall to Avoid
Do not fully evaluate central regurgitation until all guidewires are removed—heavy guidewires through the valve can hold leaflets open and cause substantial leaks that will resolve once wires are withdrawn 1.
Follow-Up Surveillance
Post-procedural regurgitation requires continued surveillance because the degree can change in subsequent days 1:
- Self-expanding valves (CoreValve) may reduce paravalvular AR as the stent continues to expand
- Conversely, recoil from compressive forces of heavy calcification can worsen the degree 1
When to Intervene
If moderate to severe paravalvular regurgitation is present, address it before leaving the procedure room 4:
- Repeat balloon dilation to achieve better seal and expansion
- Consider valve-in-valve deployment for significant central AR 1
- For self-expanding valves (CoreValve Evolut R), recapture and reposition if needed 4
Long-Term Implications
While mild paravalvular regurgitation is common and generally well-tolerated short-term, the long-term clinical significance remains uncertain 1, 2. The concern stems from surgical AVR data showing that moderate-severe AR leads to:
However, there are no reported cases of hemolysis with TAVI despite paravalvular AR 2, suggesting the hemodynamic impact may differ from surgical scenarios.
Bottom Line for Clinical Practice
When you auscultate a patient post-TAVI and hear a murmur, this is expected in most cases. The critical action is immediate echocardiographic quantification—not the presence of the murmur itself, but its severity determines prognosis and need for intervention. Mild regurgitation requires only routine monitoring, while anything beyond mild demands aggressive management to prevent the 5-fold increase in mortality risk.