How Kegel Exercises Help Despite the Internal Anal Sphincter Being Smooth Muscle
Kegel exercises (pelvic floor muscle training) work for fecal incontinence and defecatory disorders because they strengthen the external anal sphincter (EAS) and surrounding skeletal muscles of the pelvic floor, which can compensate for internal anal sphincter (IAS) dysfunction and improve overall continence through enhanced voluntary control and pelvic floor coordination. 1
The Mechanism: Why Strengthening Skeletal Muscle Matters
You're correct that the IAS is smooth muscle and cannot be directly strengthened through voluntary exercise. However, continence depends on a coordinated system involving both sphincters and the pelvic floor musculature:
The Dual Sphincter System
- Internal Anal Sphincter (IAS): Smooth muscle providing 70-80% of resting anal tone, involuntary control
- External Anal Sphincter (EAS): Skeletal muscle providing voluntary squeeze pressure and reflexive continence
- Puborectalis and levator ani: Skeletal muscles creating the anorectal angle and pelvic floor support
When the IAS is weak or damaged, strengthening the EAS and pelvic floor muscles through Kegel exercises can partially compensate by:
- Increasing voluntary squeeze pressure to prevent leakage during urgency
- Improving the anorectal angle through puborectalis strengthening
- Enhancing pelvic floor coordination and reflexive contraction timing
- Improving rectal sensation awareness, allowing earlier voluntary response 1
Clinical Evidence Supporting Kegel Exercises
For Fecal Incontinence After IAS Division
Recent research directly addresses your question. In patients who underwent partial IAS division during anal fistula surgery:
- 31% developed incontinence immediately post-surgery (mainly urge and gas incontinence)
- After regular Kegel exercises (50 repetitions daily for 1 year), incontinence dropped to 13%
- Mean incontinence scores improved from 1.19 to 0.26 (p=0.00001) 2
Even in low fistulotomy (less IAS damage):
- 20% developed post-operative incontinence
- With Kegel exercises, 50% had complete resolution and 50% had partial improvement
- Post-exercise scores became comparable to pre-operative baseline 3
Guideline Recommendations
Pelvic floor retraining with biofeedback therapy is the recommended second-line treatment for fecal incontinence after conservative measures (diet, fluids, bowel training, antidiarrheal medications). 1
For defecatory disorders, biofeedback therapy is the treatment of choice. 1
The Smooth-Skeletal Muscle Coordination
Recent anatomical research reveals that smooth and skeletal muscles in the pelvic floor work in dynamic coordination:
- Smooth muscle extends three-dimensionally throughout the pelvic floor and perineum
- At the interface between levator ani (skeletal) and pelvic viscera, smooth muscle forms structures that transfer the lifting power of skeletal muscle to the viscera
- This coordination allows skeletal muscle strengthening to indirectly influence smooth muscle function 4
Practical Implementation
Exercise Protocol
Based on the evidence, recommend:
- 50 Kegel contractions daily (hold 5-10 seconds each)
- Start 10 days post-operatively if post-surgical, or immediately if non-surgical
- Continue for at least 6-12 months for maximal benefit 2, 3
When to Escalate Beyond Kegel Exercises
If symptoms persist after 3 months of conservative therapy plus biofeedback:
- Sacral nerve stimulation for moderate-severe fecal incontinence 1
- Perianal bulking agents (dextranomer injection) as alternative 1
- Sphincteroplasty if anatomic defect present (post-obstetric injury) 1
Common Pitfall
Many patients labeled "refractory" have not received adequate conservative therapy. Before considering surgery, ensure:
- Proper characterization of bowel habits and FI circumstances
- Trial of loperamide (up to 16mg daily) for diarrhea-associated incontinence
- Dietary elimination of poorly absorbed sugars and caffeine
- Structured biofeedback therapy, not just verbal instructions for Kegel exercises 1
Bottom Line
Kegel exercises don't strengthen the IAS—they strengthen the EAS and pelvic floor skeletal muscles that compensate for IAS weakness through improved voluntary control, better anorectal angle mechanics, and enhanced neuromuscular coordination between skeletal and smooth muscle systems. The evidence shows this compensation is clinically meaningful, with significant reductions in incontinence even when the IAS has been surgically divided.