Bilateral MRI Ordering for Suspected Tarsal Coalition in a 7-Year-Old
Order bilateral foot MRI only after initial weight-bearing radiographs have been obtained, as radiography must be the first imaging study per ACR guidelines, and MRI should be reserved for cases where radiographs are non-diagnostic or to confirm suspected non-osseous coalitions 1.
Initial Imaging Algorithm
Step 1: Start with Weight-Bearing Radiographs
- Radiography is mandatory as the first-line imaging for suspected tarsal coalition 1
- Obtain lateral and oblique views of both feet
- Calcaneonavicular coalitions show 80-100% sensitivity and 97-98% specificity on plain films 1
- Talocalcaneal coalitions demonstrate 100% sensitivity and 88% specificity on radiographs 1
Step 2: Proceed to MRI When Indicated
MRI is appropriate when:
- Radiographs are negative but clinical suspicion remains high
- Indirect signs suggest coalition but no definitive diagnosis
- Non-osseous (fibrous or cartilaginous) coalition is suspected
- Assessment of associated pathologies is needed
MRI Technical Specifications
Order as follows:
- Bilateral foot MRI without contrast
- Include all three planes: sagittal, coronal (frontal), and axial sequences
- Essential sequences:
- T1-weighted in all three planes
- Fat-saturated T2-weighted in all three planes
- STIR sequences for bone marrow edema detection
Rationale: The bilateral approach is critical because tarsal coalitions are bilateral in a significant proportion of cases, and comparison views aid diagnosis 2. Non-contrast imaging is sufficient as gadolinium is not necessary for coalition diagnosis 3.
Why MRI After Radiographs?
The 2020 ACR Appropriateness Criteria explicitly state there is no relevant literature supporting MRI as the first imaging study in chronic foot pain evaluation 1. However, MRI becomes invaluable as a second-line modality because:
- 91.1% of tarsal coalitions are non-osseous (cartilaginous or fibrous), which radiographs frequently miss 4
- MRI demonstrates 95.8% sensitivity and 94.3% specificity with almost perfect inter-reader agreement 4
- In pediatric flatfoot with suspected coalition, MRI provides additional diagnostic information in 23.5% of cases where radiographs are non-contributive 5
- MRI avoids radiation exposure—particularly important in a 7-year-old who has not reached skeletal maturity 3
Key MRI Findings to Expect
Direct signs:
- Fibrous, cartilaginous, or osseous bridging between bones
- Most common locations: calcaneonavicular (33.9%) and talocalcaneal (66.1%) 4
Associated pathologies MRI will reveal:
- Adjacent bone marrow edema (57.1% of cases) 4
- Distant bone marrow edema (25% of cases) 4
- Osteochondral defects of the talar dome (19.6%) 4
- Accessory anterolateral talar facet (17.9%) 4
- Joint effusion (10.7%) 4
Innovative secondary signs:
- "Reverse anteater" sign: hyperplastic navicular (seen in 18-24% of calcaneonavicular coalitions) 2
- "Drunken waiter" sign: hypoplastic/dysplastic sustentaculum tali (69.6% of subtalar coalitions) 2
- Talar beaks (19-50% depending on location) 2
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not skip radiographs and go straight to MRI—this violates evidence-based imaging algorithms and wastes resources 1
Do not order unilateral MRI—coalitions are frequently bilateral, and comparison is diagnostically valuable 2
Do not order CT instead of MRI in children—while CT remains the traditional gold standard, MRI now shows equivalent diagnostic accuracy (95.8% sensitivity) without radiation exposure, making it superior in pediatric populations 4, 3
Ensure weight-bearing radiographs—non-weight-bearing films may miss critical alignment abnormalities associated with coalition 1
In the 7-year age group, most coalitions are not yet fully ossified—this makes MRI particularly valuable as it detects cartilaginous and fibrous forms that CT and radiographs miss 3
Clinical Context
At age 7, this patient is approaching the typical symptomatic presentation age (second decade), when progressive ossification of the coalition causes increasing stiffness and pain 6. The bilateral imaging approach is justified because it aids surgical planning if conservative management fails after the recommended 6-month trial 6.