Can Tidal Volume Be Higher Than What Was Set on Assist Control Volume Control?
No, in properly functioning assist-control volume-control (AC-VC) mode, the delivered tidal volume should match the set tidal volume for each breath—both mandatory and patient-triggered breaths receive identical volumes. However, in real-world clinical practice, several important exceptions and measurement errors can make the displayed tidal volume appear higher than the set value.
How AC-VC Mode Functions
In assist-control volume-control ventilation, the ventilator delivers a preset tidal volume regardless of whether the breath is machine-initiated or patient-triggered 1. The key principle is that "the machine delivers an identical breath to mandatory breaths" when patient triggering occurs 1. This means:
- The set tidal volume determines what is delivered
- Patient effort can trigger breaths but cannot increase the volume beyond the set value
- The ventilator is programmed with a "lock out" period to prevent breath stacking and excessive inflation 1
When Measured Tidal Volume Can Exceed Set Values
Measurement and Display Errors
The most common reason for apparent tidal volume exceeding set values involves measurement inaccuracies, not actual delivery of excess volume:
Cardiogenic oscillations: In patients with large cardiac oscillations (common post-cardiac surgery), exhaled tidal volume can be significantly overestimated—ranging from 15-260 mL above set values on certain ventilators 2. This occurs because cardiac pulsations create flow fluctuations that the ventilator's flow sensor misinterprets as exhaled volume.
Circuit compliance compensation errors: When ventilators compensate for circuit volume loss, they may either overestimate (without compensation) or underestimate (with compensation) true-delivered tidal volume 3. The error is relatively greater in infants and small children.
Fresh gas flow effects: In anesthesia ventilators, fresh gas flow can cause volume errors of 5-12.5% depending on the ventilator model 4.
Active Patient Effort During Volume Control
When patients breathe actively during volume-controlled ventilation:
- Dual-targeting ventilators (like the Servo-i) can deliver 77 mL more than set tidal volume when patients breathe actively, compared to only 37 mL more with set-point targeting ventilators 5
- This represents a clinically significant difference that could compromise lung-protective ventilation strategies
- Auto-triggering can occur with set-point targeting during active breathing, potentially delivering additional breaths 5
Double-Triggering
When ventilator inspiratory time is substantially shorter than patient inspiratory demand, "double-triggered" breaths can occur, resulting in excessive tidal volume delivery 6. This happens when:
- Patient's flow-time requirements exceed the ventilator's delivery pattern
- The patient triggers a second breath before completing exhalation
- Two set tidal volumes are delivered in rapid succession
Critical Clinical Implications
For Lung-Protective Ventilation
This issue has profound implications for ARDS management where tidal volumes >9.5 mL/kg predicted body weight suggest need for intubation in NIV patients 7, and invasive ventilation targets 6 mL/kg PBW 7, 8:
- If displayed tidal volume overestimates actual delivery, you may be under-ventilating
- If actual delivery exceeds set values due to patient effort or double-triggering, you risk ventilator-induced lung injury
- Monitored tidal volumes persistently >9.5 mL/kg PBW during NIV indicate excessive transpulmonary pressure and potential for patient self-inflicted lung injury 7, 9
Monitoring Recommendations
To avoid these pitfalls:
Don't rely solely on ventilator-displayed tidal volume—particularly in patients with:
- Large cardiogenic oscillations (post-cardiac surgery)
- Active respiratory effort during volume control
- Small body size (infants/children)
Monitor for double-triggering by observing:
- Flow-time waveforms
- Pressure-time waveforms showing two inspiratory efforts in rapid succession
- Actual delivered volumes that are multiples of set tidal volume
Assess plateau pressure and driving pressure as more reliable indicators of lung stress:
Consider switching modes if patient-ventilator dyssynchrony persists:
- Pressure-control ventilation may better match patient effort 6
- However, this sacrifices guaranteed tidal volume delivery
Common Pitfall
The most dangerous scenario occurs when clinicians assume AC-VC guarantees lung-protective ventilation simply because a low tidal volume is set. Active patient effort, particularly with high respiratory drive in ARDS, can encourage excessive transpulmonary pressure swings even in volume control mode 9, potentially causing patient self-inflicted lung injury that defeats the purpose of lung-protective strategies.