Differential Diagnosis of Gastritis-Like Symptoms
The most important conditions that mimic gastritis include functional dyspepsia (accounting for ~80% of dyspeptic symptoms), gastroesophageal reflux disease (GORD), peptic ulcer disease, irritable bowel syndrome with upper abdominal symptoms, and biliary colic. 1
Primary Functional and Structural Mimics
Functional Dyspepsia (Most Common)
Functional dyspepsia is the predominant cause of gastritis-like symptoms when endoscopy is normal, present in approximately 80% of patients with dyspepsia in the community. 1 This condition presents with:
- Epigastric pain or burning (at least 1 day/week)
- Postprandial fullness or early satiation (at least 3 days/week)
- Symptoms unrelated to defecation (distinguishing it from IBS)
- Normal endoscopy findings
The key differentiating feature is that symptoms persist despite no structural abnormalities on endoscopy.
Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease (GORD)
GORD coexists in approximately one-third of patients with dyspepsia. 1 The critical distinguishing feature is:
- Burning sensation starting in epigastrium but radiating to chest (versus isolated epigastric symptoms)
- Heartburn as predominant symptom
- May show erosive esophagitis on endoscopy (13% of dyspeptic patients) 1
Important caveat: Reflux gastritis can occur in GERD patients, with 90% of GERD patients with erosions showing histological changes of reflux gastritis. 2
Peptic Ulcer Disease
Accounts for 8% of patients with dyspeptic symptoms undergoing endoscopy. 1 Cannot be reliably distinguished from gastritis by symptoms alone—requires endoscopic visualization.
Overlapping Gastrointestinal Conditions
Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS)
Up to 50% of functional dyspepsia patients have overlapping IBS. 1 Key differentiating features:
- IBS pain is related to defecation (relieved by bowel movements or passage of gas)
- Patients with overlap report two distinct types of abdominal pain: one related and one unrelated to defecation
- Consider coeliac serology in patients with IBS-type symptoms 1
Biliary Colic
Must be distinguished from epigastric pain syndrome:
- Epigastric pain lasting <1 year with characteristics of biliary colic warrants abdominal ultrasound 1
- Pain does not fulfill biliary pain criteria in true dyspepsia 1
Less Common but Important Mimics
Post-Infectious Gastritis
Present in approximately 10% of functional dyspepsia patients. 1 Associated pathogens include:
- Norovirus
- Giardia lamblia
- Salmonella species
- E. coli O157
- Campylobacter species
Medication-Induced Gastropathy
NSAIDs are strongly associated with dyspepsia in multiple population-based studies. 1 Chemical/reactive gastropathy presents with:
- Paucity of inflammatory signs histologically (distinguishing it from true gastritis) 3
- Foveolar hyperplasia and edema
- History of NSAID use or opioids (which alter gut motility)
Atypical Presentations Requiring High Index of Suspicion
Lower lobe pneumonia can present with severe epigastric pain mimicking gastritis, particularly left lower lobe pneumonia. 4 This highlights the importance of systematic cardiopulmonary examination in all abdominal pain presentations.
Collagenous gastritis is a rare cause presenting with nausea, diarrhea, weight changes, and early satiety, requiring gastric biopsy showing thickened subepithelial collagen bands (>10 μm). 5
Critical Red Flags Requiring Urgent Investigation
Per British Society of Gastroenterology guidelines 1:
Immediate 2-week wait endoscopy for:
- Dyspepsia with weight loss if age ≥55 years
- Dyspepsia and age >40 years from high gastric cancer risk area OR family history of gastro-esophageal malignancy
Urgent CT scan for:
- Abdominal pain with weight loss if age ≥60 years
Diagnostic Approach
Baseline investigations should include 1:
- Full blood count in patients aged ≥25 years
- Coeliac serology when IBS-type symptoms overlap
- H. pylori breath or stool testing
- Abdominal ultrasound for suspected biliary colic
Common pitfall: Clinicians tend to favor GORD diagnosis over functional dyspepsia when reflux symptoms coexist, potentially missing the true underlying condition. 1 Both conditions frequently overlap and require separate consideration.