Evaluating Adults for ADHD: Essential Questions to Ask
When evaluating adults for ADHD, you must conduct a comprehensive psychiatric interview that specifically focuses on core ADHD symptoms beginning in childhood, obtain detailed substance abuse history, and critically, gather collateral information from a spouse, parent, or significant other—because adults with ADHD characteristically underestimate their symptoms and impairments 1.
Core Symptom Assessment
Childhood Onset Questions
- Ask specifically about ADHD symptoms starting before age 7 (or age 12 per DSM-5 criteria). This is non-negotiable for diagnosis 1.
- Obtain information from parents or siblings about childhood functioning, as retrospective self-reports are unreliable 2, 3.
- Use structured tools like the Wender Parent's Rating Scale or Wender Utah Rating Scales to systematically assess childhood symptoms 1.
Current Symptom Inquiry
Focus on these specific domains:
- Concentration problems and inattention
- Impulsivity and poor impulse control
- Poor anger control
- Job instability and work performance issues
- Marital difficulties and relationship problems 1
Critical Collateral Information
This is where most evaluations fail: Adults with ADHD have "notoriously poor insight" and systematically underestimate their symptoms 1. Research confirms that young adults with ADHD underreport current symptoms while those without ADHD overreport them 2.
- Always obtain information from a spouse, significant other, parent, or close friend 1
- Parent report is more diagnostically sensitive than self-report 2
- There may be no significant benefit to combining self-report with informant report beyond informant report alone 2
Substance Abuse History
Because of the high comorbidity rate, you must obtain a detailed drug and alcohol history 1:
- Current and past substance use patterns
- Consider obtaining a urine drug screen 1
- Assess for substance use disorders that may mimic or complicate ADHD
Functional Impairment Assessment
DSM criteria require impairment in at least two realms 3:
- Home functioning
- School/work performance
- Social interactions
Ask specific questions about:
- Job changes, terminations, or chronic underperformance
- Relationship instability
- Financial management problems
- Daily task completion difficulties
Differential Diagnosis Questions
Rule out conditions that masquerade as ADHD 1:
- Bipolar disorder: Ask about mood episodes, grandiosity, decreased need for sleep
- Depression: Assess for anhedonia, guilt, suicidal ideation
- Anxiety disorders: Distinguish from generalized anxiety, social phobia
- Personality disorders (especially Axis II disorders)
- Learning disabilities: Obtain educational history
- Narcolepsy: Ask about irresistible sleep attacks
- Borderline intellectual functioning: Review educational and occupational history
- Medical conditions: Thyroid disorders, sleep apnea, neurological conditions
Structured Assessment Tools
Use validated rating scales 1:
- Wender Parent's Rating Scale (for childhood symptoms)
- Wender Utah Rating Scales
- Brown Attention-Deficit Disorder Scale for Adults
- Conners Adult ADHD Rating Scale
Important caveat: While behavior rating scales alone have adequate sensitivity, they have poor specificity 4. DSM-IV items are more predictive of diagnostic group membership than adult-specific non-DSM items 2.
Medical History Components
- Complete medical history and physical examination
- Screening laboratory tests to rule out medical mimics 1
- Medication history (some medications cause attention problems)
- History of head injury or neurological illness
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Relying solely on self-report: This is the most critical error. Adults with ADHD lack insight into their deficits 1.
Missing childhood onset: ADHD by definition begins in childhood. Adult-onset "ADHD" symptoms suggest another diagnosis 1.
Overlooking substance abuse: High comorbidity rates make this essential to assess 1.
Ignoring functional impairment: Symptoms without impairment don't meet diagnostic criteria 3.
Failing to rule out bipolar disorder: This is frequently misdiagnosed as ADHD in adults 1.