Standard Postoperative Breathing Treatments
For most adult postoperative patients, provide multimodal physiotherapy combining early mobilization, deep breathing exercises, and coughing techniques, while reserving non-invasive ventilation (NIV) or high-flow oxygen (HFO) only for patients who develop postoperative hypoxemia or respiratory distress. 1
Core Breathing Treatment Protocol
The foundation of postoperative respiratory care should be multimodal physiotherapy rather than isolated chest physiotherapy 1. This approach has strong evidence (Grade 1+ and 2+) and includes:
Essential Components:
- Deep breathing exercises - These are the most feasible and best-tolerated method, causing less pain than other techniques 2
- Coughing and huffing techniques for bronchial drainage
- Early mobilization and walking - This is critical and should begin as soon as possible postoperatively 1
- Pain management education integrated into the physiotherapy program 1
Risk-Stratified Approach to Incentive Spirometry:
The evidence supports a targeted rather than universal approach:
- Low-risk patients (age <60, ASA class 1): Use simple deep breathing exercises 3
- High-risk patients (COPD GOLD 3, age >75, moderate-to-high ARISCAT score): Add incentive spirometry to the breathing exercise regimen 1, 3
This stratified approach is more resource-efficient while maintaining effectiveness, as incentive spirometry requires additional staff time (approximately 30 minutes per patient) without clear superiority over deep breathing exercises in low-risk populations 3.
When NOT to Use Advanced Respiratory Support
Do not routinely use prophylactic NIV or HFO therapy in all postoperative patients 1. The evidence is clear (Grade 2-, strong recommendation) that routine use does not reduce complication rates or length of stay in uncomplicated cases.
When TO Use Advanced Respiratory Support
Reserve NIV or HFO for treatment of established complications 1:
Specific Indications (Grade 2+, strong recommendation):
- Postoperative desaturation
- Acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS)
- Clinical hypoxemia despite standard oxygen therapy
The evidence here is compelling: In patients who develop postoperative ARDS after pulmonary resection, NIV reduced reintubation rates from 50% to 21% and mortality from 37.5% to 12.5% 1. This represents a significant mortality benefit when used appropriately.
Implementation Timeline
Postoperative Day 1:
- Begin deep breathing exercises immediately
- Initiate early mobilization protocols
- Expect highest pain levels with coughing 2
- Provide adequate analgesia to facilitate participation
Postoperative Days 2-3:
- Continue multimodal physiotherapy
- Increase frequency of exercises as pain decreases 2
- Pain differences between exercises become less significant by day 3
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Over-reliance on incentive spirometry alone - This is less effective than multimodal approaches and is rated as the most difficult exercise to perform by patients 2
Routine use of NIV/HFO - This wastes resources without improving outcomes in uncomplicated patients 1
Inadequate pain control - Coughing exercises cause the most pain and require effective analgesia for patient adherence 2. Consider regional analgesia techniques (paravertebral blocks preferred over epidurals) and short-course NSAIDs 1
Isolated chest physiotherapy - Always use multimodal approaches that include mobilization 1
Special Surgical Populations
For thoracic surgery patients specifically, the 2021 Anaesthesia guidelines provide additional context: protective one-lung ventilation intraoperatively (tidal volume 6 mL/kg with PEEP and recruitment maneuvers) sets the stage for better postoperative outcomes 1. However, the postoperative breathing treatment principles remain the same: multimodal physiotherapy with selective rather than routine advanced support.