Indications for Dilation and Curettage
Dilation and curettage (D&C) should be reserved primarily for evacuation of retained products of conception and when less invasive diagnostic methods (endometrial biopsy, hysteroscopy) have failed or are inadequate for evaluating abnormal uterine bleeding.
Primary Indications
Therapeutic Indications
- Evacuation of retained products of conception - This is the most important role of D&C 1
- Incomplete miscarriage or pregnancy failure in first trimester
- Postpartum retained placental tissue
Diagnostic Indications (When Less Invasive Methods Fail)
Abnormal uterine bleeding across all age groups when initial workup is inconclusive 2, 3:
- Childhood/adolescence: Persistent abnormal bleeding after medical management failure
- Reproductive years: Abnormal bleeding unresponsive to treatment, when endometrial biopsy inadequate
- Perimenopause/postmenopause: Unexplained bleeding requiring tissue diagnosis
Specific diagnostic scenarios:
- Suspected endometrial cancer when endometrial biopsy is non-diagnostic
- Evaluation of infertility (select cases)
- Assessment before major pelvic surgery 3
Pregnancy of Unknown Location
D&C has specific utility when β-HCG levels are 2,000-5,000 IU/L to differentiate ectopic pregnancy from nonviable intrauterine pregnancy (diagnostic rate 68.3%) 4. However, when β-HCG >5,000 IU/L with pelvic mass and no intrauterine gestational sac, proceed directly to laparoscopy as ectopic pregnancy is highly likely (96.7% rate) 4.
Critical Caveats and Modern Alternatives
Endometrial biopsy is preferred over D&C for diagnosing endometrial hyperplasia or cancer because it is less invasive, safer, and lower cost 2. D&C should only be used when:
- Endometrial biopsy yields insufficient tissue
- Focal lesions are suspected (requires hysteroscopy guidance)
- Medical treatment has failed and further investigation is needed 2
Limitations of fractional D&C: The cervical fraction has poor diagnostic accuracy with only 52.2% positive predictive value for cervical cancer and 20% contamination rate with uterine material 5. Sensitivity for cervical cancer is only 80% with specificity of 66.7% 5.
Risk Stratification for Procedure Setting
When planning D&C for first-trimester pregnancy failure, consider operating room versus clinic based on blood loss risk. Patients at higher risk for ≥200mL blood loss include 6:
- Younger age
- Higher BMI (mean 30.6 vs 27.3 kg/m²)
- Greater gestational age (mean 59.5 vs 53.6 days)
- Latina ethnicity
What D&C Should NOT Be Used For
- First-line diagnostic tool for abnormal bleeding - use endometrial biopsy instead 2
- Routine evaluation when transvaginal ultrasound and saline infusion sonohysterography can provide diagnosis
- Cervical pathology evaluation - direct biopsy is superior 5
D&C is not an innocuous procedure and carries complications, most occurring during cervical dilation 1. Clear indications must exist before proceeding, with preference given to less invasive alternatives when appropriate.