Is an Indentation at an Incisional Hernia Repair Site Normal?
A visible indentation at the site of incisional hernia repair can be a normal postoperative finding and does not necessarily indicate a complication or recurrence. This appearance may result from the mesh placement technique, tissue remodeling, or the natural contour changes that occur after repair.
Understanding Post-Repair Abdominal Wall Contour
After incisional hernia repair, the abdominal wall undergoes significant structural changes:
- Mesh placement (particularly in retromuscular or intraperitoneal positions) can create contour variations as tissues heal and incorporate around the prosthetic material
- The fascial closure itself may create a depression, especially if there was significant tissue tension during repair
- Scar tissue formation and remodeling over months can alter the surface appearance
The key distinction is between a benign contour change versus a true recurrence or complication.
When an Indentation is Concerning vs. Normal
Normal/Benign Indentation:
- Asymptomatic - no pain, discomfort, or functional limitation
- Stable appearance over time (not progressively enlarging)
- No palpable fascial defect beneath the indentation
- Soft, non-tender on examination
- No associated bulging with Valsalva maneuver
Concerning Features Requiring Evaluation:
- New or worsening pain at the site
- Progressive enlargement of the indentation
- Palpable fascial defect or gap
- Associated bulging or mass effect
- Symptoms of discomfort, especially with activity 1
Clinical Assessment Approach
Physical examination is the primary diagnostic tool:
- Palpate the area while the patient performs Valsalva maneuver to detect any fascial defect
- Assess for bulging - a true recurrence will typically show outward bulging, not just indentation
- Evaluate symptoms - patient-reported outcomes show that 63% of patients report postoperative symptoms including discomfort, pain, or bulging sensations 1
If clinical examination is equivocal:
- CT imaging is the gold standard for evaluating complex or uncertain cases 2
- Ultrasound can be useful for smaller defects
- Diagnostic laparoscopy may be warranted when imaging is inconclusive, as it can definitively distinguish between true recurrence and benign findings like encapsulated hematomas or seromas that may mimic recurrence 3
Important Context About Post-Repair Expectations
Patients should understand that perfect cosmetic results are not always achievable:
- 63% of patients report ongoing symptoms after incisional hernia repair at 3-year follow-up 1
- 20% of patients report their abdominal wall status is unchanged from preoperative state 1
- The primary goals of repair are preventing complications (incarceration, strangulation) and improving function, not necessarily achieving perfect cosmesis
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not assume an indentation equals recurrence - this can lead to unnecessary imaging, anxiety, and potentially inappropriate reoperation. True recurrences typically present with:
- Palpable fascial defect
- Outward bulging (not just indentation)
- Progressive symptoms
Imaging can be misleading - as demonstrated in a case where CT suggested recurrent hernia with bowel entrapment, but diagnostic laparoscopy revealed only a subcutaneous hematoma with intact mesh and no recurrence 3
Management Recommendation
For an asymptomatic indentation with no palpable defect:
- Reassure the patient this is likely a normal postoperative finding
- Clinical observation with periodic examination
- No imaging needed unless symptoms develop
For symptomatic or uncertain cases: