How to Diagnose Concussion
Concussion is diagnosed clinically based on a history of direct or indirect head trauma followed by the immediate presence of at least one of four key findings: confusion/disorientation, loss of consciousness, post-traumatic amnesia, or other transient neurological abnormalities, with a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 13-15. 1
Clinical Diagnostic Criteria
The diagnosis requires two essential components:
1. Mechanism of Injury
- Direct or indirect transmission of kinetic energy to the head 1, 2
- This can include direct head impact or whiplash-type forces transmitted through the body
2. Immediate Clinical Findings (within first 24 hours)
At least ONE of the following must be present and not explained by another cause 1, 2:
Cardinal Signs (highest diagnostic value):
- Observed confusion or disorientation immediately after the event 3
- Loss of consciousness (any duration ≤30 minutes) 1
- Post-traumatic amnesia (<24 hours) 1
- Convulsions or tonic posturing 2
Neurological Signs:
- Ataxia or impaired balance (within 1 day) 3
- Visual disturbances 2
- Focal neurological deficits 2
- Slower reaction time (within 2 days) 3
Cognitive Impairments:
- Impaired verbal learning and memory (within 2 days) 3
- Difficulty concentrating 2
- Feeling "in a fog" or not feeling right 2
Physical Symptoms:
Standardized Assessment Tools
The Sport Concussion Assessment Tool (SCAT) has the highest diagnostic yield (diagnostic OR 31.65) and should be the primary standardized tool used when available 4. The hierarchical ranking of diagnostic tools by accuracy is:
- SCAT (highest utility, P-score 0.97) 4
- ImPACT (computerized neurocognitive testing) 4
- Clinical presentation assessment 4
- King-Devick Test (rapid number naming/saccadic eye movement) 4
- Balance testing alone (lowest among standardized tools) 4
Role of Imaging and Biomarkers
CT Imaging
- Not required for diagnosis of uncomplicated concussion 1
- Only 7.5% of scanned patients within 24 hours show positive findings 3
- Consider CT when: GCS 13, vomiting (4 studies showed correlation), loss of consciousness with amnesia, or post-traumatic amnesia >4 hours 3
Biomarkers
- Limited clinical utility for diagnosing uncomplicated concussion 5
- High sensitivity for intracranial injury but not for concussion itself 5
- Serum ubiquitin C-terminal hydrolase and glial fibrillary acidic protein correlate with GCS 13-14 within 4 hours 3
Critical Diagnostic Pitfalls
Common mistakes to avoid:
- Do not require loss of consciousness for diagnosis - it occurs in only a minority of concussions 1
- Do not rely solely on patient self-report - confusion and disorientation must be observed and documented 3
- Do not use cognitive testing alone within 7 days - practice effects can confound results with repeated testing 3
- Do not assume normal imaging rules out concussion - concussion is a clinical diagnosis with typically normal structural imaging 1, 5
Diagnostic Algorithm
- Confirm mechanism: Direct or indirect head trauma occurred
- Identify immediate signs: Look for confusion, LOC, amnesia, or neurological abnormalities within 24 hours
- Apply standardized tool: Use SCAT6 if available for objective assessment 4
- Assess specific domains: Balance (within 1 day), reaction time (within 2 days), memory (within 2 days) 3
- Rule out alternative causes: Ensure symptoms are not better explained by other pathology 1, 2
- Consider imaging selectively: Only for red flags (GCS ≤13, persistent vomiting, focal deficits, prolonged amnesia) 3
The diagnosis remains fundamentally clinical - no single test or biomarker can definitively confirm or exclude concussion 1, 5. The CDC pediatric guideline emphasizes using the term "mild traumatic brain injury" rather than "concussion" to avoid misinterpretation, though both terms describe the same clinical entity 1.