Differential Diagnosis for Chest Pain and Shortness of Breath
In a patient presenting with chest pain and shortness of breath, you must immediately consider and rule out the life-threatening "Big Five": acute coronary syndrome (ACS), pulmonary embolism (PE), aortic dissection, tension pneumothorax, and esophageal rupture 1.
Top Priority Life-Threatening Diagnoses
1. Acute Coronary Syndrome (ACS)
- Most common serious cause requiring immediate evaluation
- Look for: retrosternal pressure/heaviness/squeezing that builds over minutes, radiation to jaw/arm/back, associated diaphoresis, nausea, or lightheadedness 1
- Critical action: Obtain ECG within 10 minutes and measure cardiac troponin immediately 1
- Special populations at higher risk:
2. Pulmonary Embolism
- Tachycardia + dyspnea present in >90% of cases 1
- Pain typically worsens with inspiration (pleuritic) 1
- Use Wells criteria for risk stratification 2, 3
3. Aortic Dissection
- Red flags: Sudden-onset "ripping" or "tearing" pain described as "worst chest pain of my life," radiating to upper or lower back 1
- Examine for pulse differential between extremities (present in 30% of cases) 1
- Higher suspicion in patients with hypertension, known bicuspid aortic valve, or connective tissue disorders (Marfan syndrome) 1
- Severe pain + pulse differential + widened mediastinum on chest X-ray = >80% probability 1
4. Tension Pneumothorax
- Dyspnea and pain worsening with inspiration 1
- Unilateral absence of breath sounds on examination 1
- Occurs in approximately 20% of esophageal rupture cases 1
5. Esophageal Rupture
- History of recent emesis is key 1
- Look for subcutaneous emphysema on examination 1
- May present with pneumothorax (20% of patients) 1
Secondary Differential Diagnoses
Cardiac (Non-ACS)
- Pericarditis: Pleuritic chest pain worse when supine, improved leaning forward; friction rub on exam; fever 1
- Myocarditis: Fever, chest pain, signs of heart failure, S3 gallop 1
- Valvular disease:
- Aortic stenosis with characteristic systolic murmur
- Aortic regurgitation with diastolic murmur 1
Pulmonary (Non-PE)
- Pneumonia: Fever, localized pleuritic pain, dullness to percussion, egophony 1, 3
- Pneumothorax (non-tension): Unilateral decreased breath sounds, pleuritic pain 1
Gastrointestinal
- GERD/Esophagitis: Burning retrosternal pain, acid regurgitation, sour/bitter taste 3
- Peptic ulcer disease/Gallbladder disease: Right upper quadrant tenderness, positive Murphy sign 1
Musculoskeletal
- Costochondritis/Tietze syndrome: Pain localized to costochondral joints, reproducible with palpation 1, 3
- Positional pain suggests musculoskeletal origin 1
Key Clinical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not rely on nitroglycerin response as diagnostic - relief with nitroglycerin does not confirm myocardial ischemia 1
Beware of atypical presentations: Sharp, stabbing, or fleeting pain lasting only seconds is unlikely ischemic, but this rule does not apply to women, elderly patients, or those with diabetes who may have atypical presentations 1
Pain characteristics that argue AGAINST ischemia:
- Localized to very limited area
- Radiates below umbilicus or to hip
- Lasts only seconds (fleeting)
- Purely positional 1
Immediate Diagnostic Algorithm
- Obtain ECG within 10 minutes looking for STEMI, new Q waves, ST changes, new T wave inversions 1
- Measure cardiac troponin immediately 1
- Perform focused cardiovascular exam checking for pulse differentials, murmurs, S3, crackles 1
- Serial ECGs if initial nondiagnostic 1
- Risk stratify based on age - the top causes vary significantly by age group 1