Difference Between Meningocele and Myeloschisis
Meningocele is a closed, skin-covered CSF-filled sac containing only meninges and no neural tissue, while myeloschisis is an open neural tube defect where exposed spinal cord tissue (placode) lies flat on the surface without any overlying sac or skin coverage.
Key Structural Differences
Meningocele 1
- Closed lesion with full-thickness skin coverage
- Contains only CSF within the sac
- No neural tissue present in the sac
- On MRI, shows only fluid without any visible neural elements
- Much less common (one-tenth the frequency of myelomeningoceles)
- Generally no neurologic deficits at presentation
Myeloschisis 2, 3, 4
- Open lesion with exposed neural tissue
- Represents the most severe form of neural tube defect
- Neural placode lies flat and exposed on the surface
- No overlying sac or membrane (distinguishing it from myelomeningocele)
- CSF leakage occurs directly from exposed neural tissue
- Always associated with significant neurologic impairment
Clinical Implications and Prognosis
Meningocele carries an excellent prognosis. Children are typically neurologically intact, though careful surgical dissection may reveal a fibrous tract that can cause cord tethering 1. The main concern is potential tethering rather than immediate neurologic dysfunction.
Myeloschisis has substantially worse outcomes compared to even myelomeningocele. Recent evidence shows that after both prenatal and postnatal repair, patients with myeloschisis require CSF diversion more frequently than those with myelomeningocele (RR 2.17 for prenatal repair, RR 1.33 for postnatal repair) 4. Additionally, myeloschisis demonstrates more severe Chiari II malformations (80% grade 3 severity vs 43% in myelomeningocele) 5 and increased rates of hindbrain herniation 4.
Embryologic Distinction
The fundamental difference lies in the embryologic failure pattern. Meningocele represents a localized defect in mesenchymal and bony closure with intact neural tube closure, resulting in herniation of only meninges 1.
Myeloschisis represents complete failure of primary neurulation where the neural tube never closes, leaving the neural placode exposed from the embryonic period 2. Importantly, meningocele is never found in the embryonic period with myeloschisis—its appearance is deferred to the fetal period, confirming these are distinct pathologic entities 2.
Critical Clinical Pitfall
Do not confuse myeloschisis with myelomeningocele. While both are open neural tube defects, myelomeningocele has a cystic sac component (even if ruptured), whereas myeloschisis never develops this sac and presents as a flat, exposed neural placode from the outset 3, 4. This distinction matters because myeloschisis requires more aggressive CSF diversion planning and has worse neurodevelopmental outcomes despite surgical repair 4, 5.