When Video-EEG and MRI Are Normal, Consider These Diagnoses
The most likely explanation for brief lip-smacking automatisms with loss of awareness when video-EEG and MRI are normal is either psychogenic non-epileptic seizures (PNES), syncope with brief automatisms, or very rarely, epileptic seizures that were not captured during monitoring.
Primary Diagnostic Considerations
1. Psychogenic Non-Epileptic Seizures (PNES)
PNES is remarkably common in this scenario. One-third of patients with presumed drug-resistant epilepsy referred to epilepsy centers actually have PNES, not epilepsy 1. This diagnosis requires video-EEG documentation of a typical event showing the clinical behavior without corresponding epileptiform activity.
Key features suggesting PNES:
- Episodes lasting >5 minutes 2
- Eye closure during unconsciousness 2
- Pelvic thrusting movements 2
- Repeated waxing and waning in intensity of movements 2
- Eye fluttering 2
2. Syncope with Automatisms
This is a critical pitfall that leads to misdiagnosis. Syncope can produce oral automatisms (lip-smacking, chewing) in 60-80% of cases 3. A videometric analysis of 56 brief syncopes demonstrated myoclonic activity in 90%, with oral automatisms frequently observed 3.
Distinguishing features of syncope:
- Duration typically <25 seconds 3
- Preceded by nausea, sweating, palpitations 4
- Triggered by prolonged standing, pain, or medical procedures 5
- Immediate return to clearheadedness (no prolonged confusion) 4
- Movements begin AFTER loss of consciousness, not before 4
The guideline explicitly warns: "Brief seizure activity can occur during syncope; when the history is clearly one of syncope, this type of seizure activity does not require neurologic investigation or referral. The inappropriate use of electroencephalography in such patients may lead to misdiagnosis" 5.
3. Epileptic Seizures Not Captured on Monitoring
While less common, this remains possible. A normal interictal EEG cannot rule out epilepsy and must be interpreted in clinical context 4. However, rare case reports document automatisms with preserved consciousness in epilepsy 6, 7, though these are exceptional.
Recommended Diagnostic Algorithm
Step 1: Detailed Witness Account
Focus on specific temporal features:
- Timing of automatisms relative to loss of awareness (simultaneous suggests epilepsy; after fall suggests syncope)
- Duration of episode (<30 seconds favors syncope; >1 minute favors epilepsy) 2
- Recovery time (immediate clearheadedness = syncope; prolonged confusion = epilepsy) 4
- Triggers present? (postural, emotional, pain = syncope) 5
Step 2: Cardiovascular Evaluation
This takes priority when video-EEG is negative 5:
- 12-lead ECG (essential initial test) 5
- Orthostatic vital signs
- Consider ambulatory ECG monitoring if episodes are frequent 5
- Echocardiography if structural heart disease suspected 5
- Tilt-table testing for recurrent episodes affecting quality of life 5
Step 3: Extended Video-EEG Monitoring
If cardiovascular workup is negative and episodes continue:
- Longer monitoring periods increase diagnostic yield 8
- Implantable loop recorders for infrequent events 5
- The goal is to capture a typical event on video-EEG 1, 8
Step 4: Psychiatric Evaluation
Screen for:
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
Do not order routine EEG for suspected syncope - this leads to false-positive findings and misdiagnosis as epilepsy 5, 4
Do not assume all automatisms = epilepsy - syncope commonly produces oral automatisms that mimic seizures 3
Do not rely on single features - tongue biting, incontinence, and brief movements occur in both syncope and seizures 4
Do not dismiss PNES - it carries significant morbidity and mortality, and early accurate diagnosis enables appropriate psychotherapy 1
When Epilepsy Remains Suspected Despite Negative Testing
If clinical features strongly suggest epilepsy (aura of unusual smell, lateral tongue bite, prolonged confusion, movements beginning before fall), referral to a comprehensive epilepsy center is warranted 1. These centers offer:
- Specialized epilepsy-protocol MRI (higher lesion detection) 1
- Prolonged video-EEG monitoring
- Multimodal imaging
- Expert seizure characterization
However, most patients with drug-resistant symptoms referred to epilepsy centers do not ultimately undergo surgery, but still benefit from comprehensive evaluation 1.