Indications for Pediatric Extracorporeal Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation (ECPR)
ECPR should be deployed for pediatric patients with in-hospital cardiac arrest (IHCA) who have refractory cardiac arrest despite conventional CPR, particularly those with underlying cardiac disease and reversible causes of arrest. 1
Primary Patient Selection Criteria
Strongest Indications (Highest Survival Rates)
Cardiac surgical patients experiencing post-operative cardiac arrest in the ICU setting 1, 2
Cardiac medical patients with structural or functional heart disease 1
- These patients show improved outcomes compared to non-cardiac populations, though lower than surgical cardiac patients 1
Favorable Characteristics for ECPR Deployment
The following factors predict better outcomes and should guide patient selection 3:
- Witnessed cardiac arrest in the ICU with active monitoring
- Ability to deliver high-quality conventional CPR while preparing for ECPR
- Potentially reversible cause of cardiac arrest identified
- Early ECPR initiation (defined as ECMO flow during active CPR or within 20 minutes of ROSC) 1
- Absence of severe acidosis and renal dysfunction 4
- Favorable initial rhythm (shockable rhythms associated with better outcomes) 4
Uncertain or Limited Indications
- Non-cardiac IHCA patients: Current evidence shows no survival difference between ECPR and conventional CPR in this population 1
- Respiratory illness as primary diagnosis: Emerging use with limited supporting evidence 1
- Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA): Insufficient data to make recommendations at this time 1
Timing Requirements
ECPR teams must be activated within 10 minutes of starting conventional CPR 5. The definition of ECPR specifically requires initiation of ECMO flow during active chest compressions or within 20 minutes of return of spontaneous circulation 1. This narrow time window is critical—delays beyond this threshold significantly worsen outcomes.
Institutional Prerequisites
ECPR requires substantial infrastructure and should only be offered when the following are in place:
- Highly trained, resourced teams available 24/7 1
- Established protocols for rapid deployment (68% of centers have institutional ECPR protocols) 5
- Primed ECMO circuit readily available (64% of centers maintain this) 5
- Experienced cannulation team (cardiac surgeons perform cannulation in 94% of centers) 5
- Appropriately equipped ICU setting for post-ECPR management 2
Special Circumstance: Post-Cardiac Surgery
For patients experiencing cardiac arrest after cardiac surgery, ECPR has particularly strong support 2:
- Odds ratio for survival of 2.2 compared to external chest compressions alone 2
- Should be considered standard protocol for at least 10 days post-operatively 2
- Can be deployed alongside or instead of emergency resternotomy 2
Critical Exclusion Considerations
While the guidelines emphasize potentially reversible causes as key to patient selection, unfavorable characteristics that may predict poor outcomes include 3:
- Unwitnessed cardiac arrest
- Inability to deliver effective conventional CPR
- Severely acidotic blood gases at presentation
- Pre-existing severe multi-organ dysfunction
- Prolonged CPR duration before ECPR initiation (though specific time cutoffs remain controversial)
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Delaying activation: Waiting too long to activate the ECPR team results in prolonged low-flow time and worse neurologic outcomes 6
Poor patient selection: Deploying ECPR in patients without reversible causes or with established multi-organ failure wastes resources without improving outcomes 3
Inadequate conventional CPR: ECPR is not a substitute for high-quality chest compressions—excellent conventional CPR must continue during ECPR preparation 6
Using ETCO2 alone for termination decisions: 47.5% of children with ETCO2 <20 mmHg during CPR survived to discharge, so low ETCO2 should not be used as sole criterion to withhold ECPR 1
Algorithmic Approach to ECPR Activation
- Cardiac arrest occurs → Initiate high-quality conventional CPR immediately
- Within 2-3 minutes → Assess for ECPR candidacy:
- Is this IHCA with witnessed arrest?
- Does patient have cardiac disease (surgical or medical)?
- Is there a potentially reversible cause?
- Can we deliver effective CPR during preparation?
- If YES to above → Activate ECPR team (within 10 minutes of CPR start)
- Continue conventional CPR with high quality while team mobilizes
- Initiate ECMO flow during active compressions or within 20 minutes of ROSC
The evidence strongly supports ECPR for pediatric cardiac patients with IHCA, while use in non-cardiac populations remains investigational and should be approached with caution given current evidence showing no survival benefit. 1