Management of Hand Osteoarthritis with Flexion Contractures in a 78-Year-Old Woman
For this 78-year-old woman with hand osteoarthritis presenting with flexed ("drawn up") hands, you should prioritize a combination of hand exercises and thumb base orthoses (if thumb CMC joint is involved) as the foundation of treatment, supplemented by topical NSAIDs as first-line pharmacological therapy. 1
Non-Pharmacological Interventions (First-Line)
Hand Exercises - Strongly Recommended
- Exercises to improve function and muscle strength while reducing pain should be offered to every patient with hand OA 1
- The 2019 ACR/AF guidelines made a strong recommendation for regular, ongoing exercise programs 2
- Recent meta-analyses show low-certainty evidence for a small long-term effect on pain, with moderate-certainty evidence for functional improvement 3
- Exercise effectiveness is enhanced when coupled with self-management programs 2
Orthoses/Splinting
- For thumb base (CMC joint) involvement: Long-term orthosis use is strongly recommended with moderate-certainty evidence showing reduced pain at medium term (SMD = -0.70) and long-term follow-up (SMD = -0.80), plus improved function (SMD = 0.42) 1, 4
- For other finger joints: Conditional recommendation, but still beneficial 2
- The "drawn up" presentation suggests possible thumb base involvement or multiple joint contractures where splinting can provide mechanical support
Education and Joint Protection
- Education on ergonomic principles, pacing of activity, and use of assistive devices should be offered to every patient 1
- Assistive devices have moderate-certainty evidence for moderate long-term effect on function 3
- This is particularly important for maintaining independence in a 78-year-old
Pharmacological Interventions (Second-Line)
Topical NSAIDs - First Pharmacological Choice
- Topical NSAIDs are preferred over systemic treatments due to safety reasons and are the first pharmacological topical treatment of choice 1
- Recent 2026 meta-analysis showed topical NSAIDs demonstrated the greatest overall treatment effects on pain (SRM = -1.69), function (SRM = -0.99), and stiffness (SRM = -1.43) among all pharmacological interventions 5
- Critical caveat: Approximately 70% of this effect is attributable to contextual (placebo) effects, but they remain superior for functional improvement 5
- High-certainty evidence for small short-term effect on function 3
Oral NSAIDs - If Topical Insufficient
- Oral NSAIDs should be considered for limited duration for symptom relief 1
- Low-certainty evidence for moderate short-term effect on pain 3
- In a 78-year-old, carefully assess cardiovascular, renal, and GI risk before prescribing
Alternative Pharmacological Options
- Chondroitin sulfate: May be used for pain relief and improved function (Level 1b evidence), though this had the lowest level of agreement (7.3/10) among EULAR recommendations 1
- Oral glucocorticoids (low-dose): Moderate-certainty evidence for small short-term effect on function 3
Interventional Procedures
Intra-articular Injections - For Refractory Cases
- For interphalangeal joints: Glucocorticoid injections may be considered for painful joints 1, 6
- Avoid routine use in hand OA generally, but can be considered for specific painful interphalangeal joints 1
- Recent 2025 evidence shows platelet-rich plasma (PRP) and dextrose prolotherapy have significant long-term benefits (≥6 months):
Surgical Considerations
- For joints that remain mobile but painful despite conservative treatment: Joint denervation should be considered as it preserves anatomy, maintains range of motion, and has low complication rates 8
- For advanced disease with fixed contractures: More definitive procedures (arthrodesis, arthroplasty, trapeziectomy for thumb base) may be necessary 9
- The "drawn up" presentation suggests possible fixed contractures that may eventually require surgical evaluation if conservative measures fail
Critical Clinical Algorithm
- Start immediately: Hand exercises + education on joint protection
- Add orthoses: Especially if thumb base involved (long-term use)
- Add topical NSAIDs: First pharmacological choice for safety in elderly
- If insufficient after 4-6 weeks: Consider oral NSAIDs (short course) or chondroitin sulfate
- For persistent pain in specific joints: Consider intra-articular glucocorticoid injections (interphalangeal joints) or PRP/dextrose for longer-lasting effect
- If conservative treatment fails after 3-6 months: Refer for surgical evaluation (denervation if mobile, more definitive surgery if fixed contractures)
Important Caveats
- No disease-modifying agents exist - all treatments are symptomatic 2, 9
- Age considerations: At 78, prioritize safety with topical over oral medications when possible
- The "drawn up" presentation may indicate more advanced disease or fixed contractures that could limit benefit from exercises alone - early occupational therapy referral is crucial
- Multidisciplinary approach: Optimal management usually requires involvement of rheumatology, occupational therapy, and potentially hand surgery 1