Differential Diagnoses for Head Trauma
When evaluating a patient presenting after head trauma, the primary differential diagnoses include intracranial hemorrhages (subdural, epidural, subarachnoid, intraparenchymal), cerebral contusions, depressed skull fractures, diffuse axonal injury, and traumatic brain injury with or without clinically important brain injury (CIBI). 1
Acute Traumatic Intracranial Pathology
The most critical differential diagnoses to identify immediately are those requiring neurosurgical intervention or hospital admission:
Life-Threatening Injuries
- Subdural hematoma - particularly in elderly patients or those on anticoagulation
- Epidural hematoma - classic presentation with lucid interval
- Intraparenchymal hematoma/hemorrhage
- Subarachnoid hemorrhage (traumatic)
- Cerebral contusion - especially at frontal and temporal poles
- Depressed skull fractures - particularly those penetrating the inner table
- Diffuse axonal injury - associated with severe mechanisms and poor outcomes 1
Skull Fractures
- Open skull fractures - high risk for infection and neurosurgical intervention
- Basal skull fractures - indicated by Battle's sign, raccoon eyes, hemotympanum, CSF rhinorrhea/otorrhea
- Closed depressed skull fractures 1
Clinically Unimportant Lesions
Important caveat: Not all CT findings require intervention. Clinically unimportant lesions include:
- Solitary contusions <5 mm diameter
- Localized subarachnoid blood <1 mm thick
- Smear subdural hematomas <4 mm thick
- Isolated pneumocephaly
- Closed depressed skull fractures not through inner table 1
Non-Traumatic Mimics and Alternative Diagnoses
In Pediatric Populations
When subdural hemorrhage is present in infants, consider:
- Abusive head trauma (non-accidental trauma) - most common cause of traumatic death in infants <1 year 2, 3, 4
- Bleeding disorders (hemophilia, von Willebrand disease, thrombocytopenia)
- Metabolic diseases
- Benign enlargement of subarachnoid spaces (BESS)
- Cerebral arteriovenous malformations 3, 5, 4
In Adult Populations
- Chronic subdural hematoma - gradual decline after seemingly minor trauma, especially in elderly
- Underlying coagulopathy - presenting as hemorrhage after minor trauma
- Pre-existing neurologic conditions unmasked by trauma
- Psychiatric conditions contributing to presentation 6, 7
Subacute/Chronic Presentations
For patients presenting days to weeks after trauma with persistent symptoms:
- Post-concussive syndrome
- Chronic traumatic encephalopathy (in repetitive trauma)
- Delayed subdural hematoma
- Focal encephalomalacia from previous contusions
- Microbleeds from traumatic axonal injury
- Depression, anxiety, PTSD as post-injury psychiatric morbidity 8, 6
Risk Stratification Approach
Use validated clinical decision tools to stratify risk and guide imaging:
High-Risk Features (100% sensitive for neurosurgical intervention) 1:
- Failure to reach GCS 15 within 2 hours
- Suspected open skull fracture
- Signs of basal skull fracture
- Vomiting >1 episode
- Age >64 years
Additional High-Risk Criteria (NEXUS) 1:
- Evidence of skull fracture
- Scalp hematoma
- Neurologic deficit
- Abnormal level of alertness
- Abnormal behavior
- Persistent vomiting
- Coagulopathy
- Age ≥65 years
Medium-Risk Features for CIBI 1:
- Headache
- Drug or alcohol intoxication
- Deficits in short-term memory
- Physical evidence of trauma above clavicles
- Post-traumatic seizure
Common Pitfalls
Critical errors to avoid:
- Missing abusive head trauma in pediatric patients by attributing subdural hemorrhage solely to minor accidental trauma 2, 3, 5
- Failing to consider underlying bleeding disorders when hemorrhage seems disproportionate to mechanism 3, 4
- Dismissing elderly patients with "minor" falls who may develop delayed subdural hematomas 8
- Overlooking psychiatric or substance use contributions to presentation and mechanism 6, 7
- Using clinical decision tools as the sole determinant rather than incorporating clinical judgment 1