Surgical Excision of Keloids in the Operating Theatre
Keloids should be surgically excised followed immediately by adjuvant therapy—most effectively postoperative brachytherapy (3-15% recurrence) or superficial radiation therapy within 24-48 hours, combined with intralesional triamcinolone injections starting within one week post-operatively.
Surgical Technique
Preoperative Planning
- Mark the keloid boundaries and plan incisions along scar margins to avoid creating new scars
- For large keloids (>8 cm), consider tissue expansion as a first stage 1
- Assess anatomic location—auricular keloids may benefit from core excision techniques
Excision Methods
Standard excision involves removing tissue to the depth of subcutaneous fat to completely eliminate the sinus tract 2. The procedure can be performed using:
- Scalpel
- Electrosurgery
- Ablative CO2 laser (10,600 nm at 55W continuous wave for improved hemostasis and visualization) 2
For auricular keloids specifically, use a core excision technique with a skin biopsy punch to retain overlying skin and minimize wound tension 3, 4. This "hollowing out method" preserves the skin envelope while removing the keloid core, reducing operative time and preventing ear deformity.
For large keloids, employ a modified tension-reduction technique: reduce tension in an area three times larger than the residual wound to decrease recurrence 5.
Anesthesia
Use local infiltration or tumescent technique—this reduces bleeding risk and toxicity in larger cases 2.
Closure
- Primary linear closure is preferred when feasible—avoid skin grafting as it shows inferior outcomes 6
- Close along the original scar boundary to prevent new scar formation 1
- Ensure tension-free closure
Critical Adjuvant Therapy Protocol
Radiation therapy timing is crucial: Begin within 24-48 hours postoperatively for optimal results 6.
Radiation Options (in order of efficacy):
- Brachytherapy: 3.1-15% recurrence—most effective 7
- Superficial radiation therapy (SRT): 3 consecutive days, maximum cumulative dose 18 Gy, achieving 81% remission 8
- Beta ray radiotherapy: 12-15 Gy total over 10 treatments across 2 weeks (95.8% efficacy vs. 91.3% for 5 treatments over 1 week) 6
Intralesional Corticosteroid Protocol
- Start within one week after suture removal 4
- Use triamcinolone acetonide
- Continue every 2 weeks for 4-6 injections 4
- Recurrence rates: 6.6-33% depending on protocol 7
Optional Adjuncts
- Silicone gel sheeting for 3-6 months improves texture and color but doesn't significantly affect recurrence 6
- 5-fluorouracil for refractory cases reduces recurrence compared to surgery alone 7
Critical Pitfalls to Avoid
⚠️ Never perform excision alone—recurrence rates are unacceptably high without adjuvant therapy 9, 7
⚠️ Do not delay radiation therapy—the 24-48 hour window is critical for efficacy 6
⚠️ Avoid skin grafting when primary closure is possible—grafted wounds show worse outcomes 6
⚠️ Do not skip postoperative corticosteroid injections—one patient in a recent series relapsed specifically due to missing these injections 4
⚠️ If patient was on isotretinoin, delay elective keloid procedures for 6-12 months due to delayed wound healing and keloid formation risk 10
Expected Outcomes
With proper multimodal treatment:
- Overall recurrence: 13-19% 8, 7
- Significant reduction in Vancouver Scar Scale scores 11, 5
- 95% patient satisfaction with marked improvement 11
The evidence strongly supports that combination therapy consistently outperforms monotherapy across all studies 9, 7.