PCL Tear Presentation
PCL tears typically present with posterior knee pain, a history of direct anterior tibial trauma (dashboard injury) or hyperextension, and the pathognomonic "posterior sag sign" where the tibial tubercle appears to disappear when the knee is flexed to 90 degrees due to gravity-assisted posterior tibial displacement 1, 2.
Mechanism of Injury
The most common injury mechanism differs significantly from ACL tears:
- Dashboard injury: Direct blow to the proximal anterior tibia with knee flexed (motor vehicle accidents) - this is the classic isolated PCL tear mechanism 1
- Sports trauma: Direct blow to anterior tibia during knee flexion in contact sports like soccer 1
- High-energy trauma: Hyperextension, hyperflexion, or rotational injuries with valgus/varus stress - these typically involve multiple ligament injuries 1, 3
Important caveat: Isolated PCL tears are frequently misdiagnosed because they are less symptomatic than ACL tears and easily overlooked 2.
Clinical Presentation
Symptoms
- Posterior knee pain, particularly severe in >90° of flexion 2
- Knee instability (though often less dramatic than ACL tears) 4
- Mechanical symptoms if associated meniscal injury present 5
- Symptoms may be subtle in isolated tears, leading to delayed presentation 2
Physical Examination Findings
Positive findings (in order of diagnostic utility):
Posterior sag sign (most characteristic):
Posterior drawer test:
Quadriceps active test:
Knee hyperextension sign: Present but nonspecific 1
Dial test: Assess for posterolateral corner injury (associated injuries) 2
Negative findings that help differentiate from ACL tears:
Associated Injuries to Assess
Critical: Always evaluate for associated injuries as their presence changes management from conservative to surgical 4:
- Vascular injury: Occurs in ~30% of posterior knee dislocations - requires immediate assessment 6
- Collateral ligament injuries (valgus/varus testing) 2
- Meniscal tears 5
- Posterolateral corner injuries 2
- Bony avulsion fractures 6
Grading System
- Grade I: Partial tear, <5mm posterior tibial translation
- Grade II: Complete tear, 5-10mm posterior tibial translation
- Grade III: Complete tear with >10mm posterior tibial translation, often with associated injuries 7, 3
Imaging Confirmation
While clinical diagnosis is primary, MRI is the gold standard for visualizing acute PCL tears 7, 3. PCL stress radiography provides objective assessment of posterior tibial translation, with ≥8mm side-to-side difference indicating grade II or higher injury 7.
Ultrasound finding: PCL thickness ≥6.5mm suggests PCL injury 6, though US has limited visualization of cruciate ligaments 6.
Common Pitfalls
- Missing the diagnosis entirely: PCL tears are less symptomatic than ACL tears and easily overlooked in polytrauma 2
- Failing to assess for vascular injury: Critical in high-energy trauma or knee dislocations 6
- False negative posterior drawer test: Particularly common in acute presentations due to hemarthrosis and guarding 1
- Assuming isolated injury: Always evaluate for associated ligamentous, meniscal, and neurovascular injuries as these determine surgical vs. conservative management 4, 2