Defining High-Risk Patients
High-risk patients are those at elevated risk for adverse outcomes such as hospitalization or death, characterized by multiple chronic conditions, advanced age, functional impairment, mental health/substance use disorders, social instability, and specific disease-related factors.
Core Clinical and Demographic Characteristics
Based on expert consensus from the VHA quality measures panel 1, high-risk patients represent a heterogeneous population that includes:
Primary Risk Categories
- Multiple chronic conditions (multimorbidity)
- Older adults with frailty
- Mental health and/or substance use disorders
- Unstable housing or homelessness
- Terminal illness diagnoses
Cross-Cutting Risk Factors
The expert panel identified several common issues that span across disease states 1:
Social determinants:
- Social isolation
- Low health literacy
- Financial insufficiency
- Food insecurity
- Mistrust of the health care system
Functional and access issues:
- Impaired functional status
- Limited health care access
- Poor adherence to care plans
Specific High-Risk Markers
For Healthcare-Associated Infections
Patients at admission with 2:
- Cancer diagnosis
- Cardiovascular disease
- Chronic renal failure
- Diabetes
- Emergency admission status
- Recent ICU or high-dependency unit stay
- Surgery within 30 days before admission
- Total length of stay >30 days in the preceding 2 years
For Persistent High Risk
Research demonstrates that only about one-third of initially high-risk patients remain persistently high-risk over time 3, 4. Predictors of remaining persistently high-risk include 3:
- Urban residence
- Chronic medical comorbidities
- Auditory and visual impairment
- Chronic pain
- Any cancer diagnosis
- Social instability markers
For Cardiovascular Disease
In the primary prevention context, high-risk patients have 5:
- Subclinical atherosclerosis (detected by biomarkers or imaging)
- Elevated blood pressure
- Elevated total cholesterol
- Diabetes mellitus
- Overweight status
- Current smoking
- Physical inactivity
Socioeconomic Risk Amplification
Lower socioeconomic status dramatically amplifies risk profiles 6. These patients are:
- A decade younger when presenting with cardiovascular disease
- 5.8 times more likely to be current smokers
- 1.7 times more likely to have elevated depressive symptoms
- Have significantly higher BMI, waist circumference, and HbA1c
- Have lower cardiorespiratory fitness despite younger age
Critical Clinical Pitfall
A single point-in-time risk assessment is insufficient. Research shows that 65% of patients initially identified as high-risk will decrease to moderately high or low risk within 2 years, while 35% remain persistently high-risk 4. This means interventions must be tailored based on longitudinal risk patterns, not just baseline assessment. Programs that identify patients based on a single high-risk score may spuriously appear effective due to natural regression to the mean 3.
Practical Application
When identifying high-risk patients in primary care, assess for:
- Number of chronic conditions (≥3 suggests high complexity)
- Recent healthcare utilization (hospitalizations, ED visits in past 90 days)
- Social instability markers (housing, food security, social support)
- Functional impairment (ADL/IADL limitations)
- Mental health comorbidity (depression, anxiety, substance use)
- Age-related vulnerability (frailty in older adults, premature disease in younger adults with low SES)
The VHA expert panel emphasized that high-risk patients require assessment of issues beyond traditional disease-specific quality measures, focusing instead on comprehensive, patient-centered, coordinated care that addresses their complex, cross-cutting needs 1.