What Constitutes a Positive McMurray Test
A positive McMurray test is defined by the presence of a palpable or audible "thud" or "click" along the joint line during the maneuver, with or without associated pain, elicited while the knee is flexed and the tibia is rotated while extending the knee.
Key Findings That Define a Positive Test
The most specific finding is:
- A palpable "thud" on the medial joint line when testing for medial meniscal tears (specificity 98%, positive predictive value 83%) 1
- An audible or palpable "click" during the rotational component of the test 2
- Pain along the joint line during the maneuver, though this is less specific 3
How to Interpret the Test
The McMurray test should be understood within these parameters:
For medial meniscal tears:
- Internal rotation of the tibia with knee extension typically produces findings on the lateral joint line
- However, paradoxical findings can occur where internal rotation produces medial-sided symptoms in specific tear patterns (anteriorly-based posterior oblique tears, bucket-handle tears, or peripheral detachment of discoid menisci) 2
For lateral meniscal tears:
- External rotation of the tibia with knee extension typically produces findings on the medial joint line
- Similar paradoxical patterns may occur 2
Clinical Performance and Limitations
The McMurray test has moderate diagnostic utility 4:
- Sensitivity: 16-58.5% (meaning many meniscal tears will be missed) 1, 5
- Specificity: 91-98% (meaning a positive test is highly suggestive of pathology) 1, 5, 3
Critical caveat: The test is more strongly associated with ICRS Grade 4 chondral lesions (86% positive) compared to Grade 3 lesions (30% positive), suggesting it may reflect combined meniscal-chondral pathology rather than isolated meniscal tears 6. When positive, consider concomitant articular cartilage injury.
Important Clinical Pitfalls
Concomitant cartilage injury does NOT significantly affect McMurray test performance (P = .667 for medial, P = .064 for lateral compartments) 3, so the test remains reliable even in degenerative knees
The test should be combined with other examination findings (joint line tenderness, Thessaly test) for optimal diagnostic accuracy 4—using McMurray in isolation is insufficient
Examiner experience has minimal effect on accuracy 1, so the test is reproducible across skill levels
A positive McMurray test in younger patients with acute traumatic onset is more likely to represent a true meniscal tear 7, while in older patients with insidious onset, consider chronic degenerative pathology with bone bruising 7
Practical Algorithm
When McMurray test is positive (thud/click ± pain):
- High specificity → proceed with MRI for definitive diagnosis 4
- Consider concomitant chondral injury, especially if Grade 4 lesions suspected 6
- Combine with joint line tenderness findings (though note: medial joint line tenderness loses accuracy with medial compartment cartilage injury, OR 0.10, P = .027) 3
When McMurray test is negative: