Yes, setting the dialysis machine bicarbonate to 38 mmol/L is appropriate and safe for this patient.
For a chronic dialysis patient with low predialysis serum bicarbonate and a PaCO₂ of 32 mmHg (indicating chronic respiratory alkalosis or compensation), increasing the dialysate bicarbonate concentration to 38 mmol/L is explicitly supported by established guidelines and is a safe, effective intervention to correct metabolic acidosis. 1
Guideline-Based Rationale
The NKF-K/DOQI Clinical Practice Guidelines for Nutrition in Chronic Renal Failure specifically state that higher concentrations of bicarbonate in hemodialysate (38 mmol/L) have been shown to safely increase predialysis serum bicarbonate concentrations 1. The target is to maintain predialysis serum bicarbonate at or above 22 mmol/L, as metabolic acidosis is associated with:
- Increased protein degradation and decreased albumin synthesis
- Increased oxidation of branched-chain amino acids
- Adverse effects on nutritional status
- Potentially increased morbidity 1
Clinical Context: The PaCO₂ of 32 mmHg
The low PaCO₂ (32 mmHg, normal ~40 mmHg) indicates either:
- Chronic respiratory alkalosis (less likely in a dialysis patient without lung disease)
- Respiratory compensation for metabolic acidosis (the patient is hyperventilating to blow off CO₂)
In either scenario, correcting the metabolic acidosis with higher dialysate bicarbonate is appropriate. The patient's respiratory system will adjust accordingly—if they have primary metabolic acidosis, their respiratory drive will decrease as acidosis corrects; if they have primary respiratory alkalosis, the higher bicarbonate will help maintain pH balance.
Safety Considerations
Evidence on Safety and Efficacy:
- A 1997 randomized trial found that 40 mmol/L bicarbonate dialysate was safe, well-tolerated, and produced better control of acidosis with improved nutritional markers (triceps skinfold thickness) compared to 30 mmol/L 2
- Recent 2024 research showed that dialysate bicarbonate ≥38 mmol/L increased predialysis serum bicarbonate by approximately 0.9 mmol/L compared to 35 mmol/L, with 91% of patients achieving target bicarbonate ≥22 mmol/L 3
Potential Concerns (Nuanced Discussion):
Post-dialysis alkalosis: Higher dialysate bicarbonate can cause transient metabolic alkalosis immediately after dialysis. A 2024 study found that 38 mmol/L (vs 30 mmol/L) was associated with alkalosis, hypocalcemia, and more pronounced hypokalemia during treatment 4. However, the clinical significance of transient post-dialysis alkalosis in achieving adequate predialysis correction remains debatable.
Mortality data: A 2013 DOPPS observational study suggested a modest association between dialysate bicarbonate ≥38 mmol/L and increased mortality (HR 1.07,95% CI 0.97-1.19), particularly with longer dialysis vintage 5. However, this was observational data with potential unmeasured confounding, and the association was not statistically significant. The proposed mechanism was post-dialysis metabolic alkalosis, but this must be weighed against the well-established harms of chronic metabolic acidosis.
Hemodynamic effects: The 2024 hemodynamic study showed that high dialysate bicarbonate (38 mmol/L) was associated with greater decreases in stroke volume and blood pressure compared to 30 mmol/L 4. This is relevant if your patient has intradialytic hypotension, but the NKF-K/DOQI guidelines address this by recommending bicarbonate-buffered dialysate over acetate to minimize hypotension 6.
Practical Algorithm
For your patient with low predialysis bicarbonate and PaCO₂ 32 mmHg:
- Increase dialysate bicarbonate to 38 mmol/L 1
- Monitor predialysis serum bicarbonate monthly (guideline recommendation) 1
- Check post-dialysis bicarbonate and pH after 1-2 weeks to assess for excessive alkalosis
- Monitor for intradialytic hypotension—if this worsens, consider:
- Monitor serum calcium and potassium closely in the first few sessions, as higher bicarbonate can cause transient hypocalcemia and hypokalemia 4
Alternative: Oral Bicarbonate Supplementation
If you prefer not to increase dialysate bicarbonate, oral sodium bicarbonate (2-4 g/day or 25-50 mEq/day) is equally effective 1. A 2025 randomized trial showed equivalent effects between oral supplementation and increased dialysate bicarbonate 7. However, dialysate adjustment is simpler and doesn't require patient adherence to additional medications.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Don't avoid correcting acidosis due to fear of alkalosis: The harms of chronic metabolic acidosis (protein catabolism, bone disease, increased mortality risk) outweigh the theoretical risks of transient post-dialysis alkalosis
- Don't assume the low PaCO₂ is a contraindication: It's likely respiratory compensation for metabolic acidosis, which will self-correct as acidosis improves
- Don't use excessively high bicarbonate (>40 mmol/L) without close monitoring, as this increases risk of significant alkalosis
- Monitor for hypocalcemia and hypokalemia in the initial period after increasing dialysate bicarbonate 4
In summary: Yes, change the bicarbonate to 38 mmol/L. This is guideline-supported, safe, and addresses the underlying metabolic acidosis while the patient's respiratory system adjusts accordingly.