AV Fistula Obliteration/Closure Procedures
The procedure to permanently close a failed arteriovenous fistula is called AV access abandonment, which can be accomplished through either surgical ligation or endovascular embolization/occlusion techniques.
Primary Approach: Surgical Ligation
When an AV fistula can no longer provide adequate flows for dialysis, is deemed unsafe, and cannot be corrected by any intervention (medical, surgical, or radiologic), it meets criteria for abandonment 1. The traditional approach involves surgical ligation of the fistula, typically performed by vascular surgery.
Alternative: Endovascular Closure
Endovascular techniques have emerged as viable alternatives to open surgery for fistula closure, particularly in specific clinical scenarios:
Endovascular Closure Techniques Include:
- Coil embolization - Using detachable or non-detachable coils to occlude the fistula 2, 3
- Covered stent-graft placement - Deploying a covered stent across the arteriovenous connection to exclude the fistula 4, 5
- Occlusion devices - Using septal occluders or other closure devices originally designed for cardiac defects 6, 7
- Balloon embolization - Detachable balloons can be used for larger fistulas 2
When to Consider Each Approach
Surgical ligation remains the standard when:
- The fistula has definitively failed and requires permanent closure
- There are no plans for future access creation in that location
- The anatomy is straightforward and accessible
Endovascular closure is particularly appealing when:
- The surgical field is heavily scarred from previous procedures 7
- The patient has significant comorbidities making surgery higher risk
- The fistula anatomy is complex or in a difficult surgical location 6
Important Caveats
Before proceeding with permanent closure, ensure the fistula truly meets abandonment criteria per KDOQI guidelines 1:
- Unable to provide adequate dialysis flows
- Cannot be corrected by any intervention
- Alternative access is established or planned
Do not confuse abandonment with salvage attempts. The 2023 ACR guidelines emphasize that endovascular management (thrombectomy, angioplasty, stenting) should be attempted first for thrombosed or malfunctioning fistulas before considering permanent closure 8. Only after failed salvage attempts or when the fistula is deemed unsalvageable should permanent closure be pursued.
Practical Algorithm
- Confirm abandonment criteria - Document that the fistula cannot be salvaged
- Ensure alternative access - Place tunneled catheter or create new access before closure
- Choose closure method:
- Default to surgical ligation for straightforward cases
- Consider endovascular if scarred field, high surgical risk, or complex anatomy
- Refer appropriately - Vascular surgery for ligation, interventional radiology for endovascular closure
The choice between surgical and endovascular approaches should be based on local expertise, patient anatomy, and surgical history rather than a rigid protocol.