Hip Arthroplasty vs Total Hip Replacement for Displaced Femoral Neck Fractures
In properly selected patients with displaced femoral neck fractures, total hip arthroplasty (THA) offers functional benefits and lower revision rates compared to hemiarthroplasty (HA), but patient selection is critical—reserve THA for healthier, more active, independently ambulatory patients, while HA remains appropriate for frail, multimorbid elderly patients.
Patient Selection Algorithm
The choice between THA and HA hinges on three key factors:
Choose THA when:
- Patient is independently ambulatory pre-fracture (walking without assistance from another person)
- Age < 80-85 years with good functional status
- ASA grade ≤ 2-3
- Life expectancy > 2-5 years
- Pre-existing hip osteoarthritis present
- Patient accepts slightly higher complication risk for better function
Choose HA when:
- Patient has significant comorbidities (ASA ≥ 3-4)
- Age > 85 years with limited mobility
- Limited pre-fracture ambulatory status
- Significant cognitive impairment/dementia
- Medical frailty prioritizes minimizing surgical time and complications
Evidence-Based Outcomes
The 2022 AAOS guidelines provide a moderate strength recommendation that THA may offer functional benefit over HA in properly selected patients with displaced femoral neck fractures, though this comes with increased complication risk 1222. This recommendation was notably downgraded from strong to moderate despite strong evidence for functional benefit, specifically because of the increased complication risk 2.
Functional Outcomes:
The most recent 2025 overview of systematic reviews (29,980 patients) demonstrates THA provides:
- Better early function (SMD 0.59,95% CI 0.04-1.08) 3
- Better quality of life (mean difference 0.05,95% CI 0.03-0.08) 3
- Lower revision rate (RR 0.67,95% CI 0.48-0.93) 3
However, the landmark 2019 NEJM trial (1,495 patients, 80 centers) found these functional improvements were clinically unimportant—below established cutoffs for minimal important difference 4. The 2020 JBJS meta-analysis similarly concluded the quality of life benefit with THA was small and possibly unimportant (MD 0.05, well below the 0.145 minimally important difference) 5.
Complication Profile:
- No significant difference in dislocation rates, periprosthetic fractures, infection, or mortality between THA and HA 354
- THA has 20 minutes longer operative time on average 35
- At 120-day follow-up, HA showed lower surgical complication rates (4% vs 10%, p=0.006) in orthogeriatric patients 6
- THA patients had higher serious adverse event rates (41.8% vs 36.7%) 4
Revision Risk:
THA demonstrates clear superiority with lower revision rates (RR 4.14 for HA vs THA in active elderly) 7, though the absolute 5-year revision risk remains low at 3.2% overall 8.
Critical Nuances
The 2022 AAOS guideline workgroup specifically downgraded their recommendation from strong to moderate despite strong evidence for functional benefit, explicitly acknowledging the increased complication risk with THA 2. This reflects real-world clinical judgment that functional gains must be weighed against safety.
The 2022 German orthogeriatric registry analysis (4,662 HA vs 892 THA patients) provides crucial insight: "Not the age of the patient but the preoperative condition might be important for the choice" 6. THA patients showed better walking ability (28% vs 18% independent at 120 days) and quality of life, but HA had fewer complications in multimorbid patients 6.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Don't use age alone as the deciding factor—functional status and comorbidities matter more than chronological age 68
Don't assume THA is always superior—the functional benefits are modest and may not reach clinical importance thresholds in many patients 54
Don't overlook pre-existing hip arthritis—this strongly favors THA as demonstrated in the AAOS case example 1
Use cemented femoral stems regardless of choice (strong AAOS recommendation) to reduce periprosthetic fracture risk 222
Consider dual-mobility constructs for THA to mitigate dislocation risk, though registry data shows similar revision rates 8
The evidence supports THA for healthier, active patients who can tolerate the procedure and benefit from improved function, while HA remains the safer choice for frail, multimorbid elderly patients where minimizing complications takes priority over marginal functional gains.