Switching from Gardasil 9 to Gardasil 4 After First Dose is Not Recommended
You should not switch from Gardasil 9 to Gardasil 4 (which is no longer available) after the first dose; complete the vaccination series with Gardasil 9 as originally started. Studies on mixed HPV vaccine regimens to assess interchangeability were not performed for Gardasil 9, and the FDA label explicitly states this lack of interchangeability data 1.
Key Points on Gardasil 9 Dosing
Complete the Series with the Same Vaccine
- Gardasil 9 must be continued through all doses once started 1
- No evidence supports switching between different HPV vaccine formulations mid-series
- Gardasil 4 (the quadrivalent vaccine) has been largely replaced by Gardasil 9 in most markets
Dosing Schedule Options
The appropriate regimen depends on age at first dose 1:
Ages 9-14 years:
- 2-dose schedule: Second dose at 6-12 months after first dose
- 3-dose schedule: 0,2,6 months (alternative option)
- Critical timing rule: If second dose given <5 months after first dose, a third dose is required at least 4 months after the second dose
Ages 15-45 years:
- 3-dose schedule only: 0,2,6 months
If a Dose is Missed
- Continue the series where it was interrupted 1
- Do not restart the entire series
- Maintain the appropriate intervals between remaining doses
- The series does not need to be restarted if the interval is longer than recommended
Why This Matters
Gardasil 9 provides broader protection than Gardasil 4:
- Covers 9 HPV types (6,11,16,18,31,33,45,52,58) versus 4 types in the older vaccine
- Protects against additional cancer-causing HPV types (31,33,45,52,58) 1
- Switching to a vaccine with less coverage would compromise protection against these additional high-risk types
Common Pitfall to Avoid
Do not confuse "switching vaccines" with "previously vaccinated with Gardasil 4." The FDA label addresses individuals who completed a full Gardasil 4 series and later received Gardasil 9 as a separate intervention 1. This is entirely different from switching mid-series, which lacks safety and efficacy data.
Bottom line: Complete all doses with Gardasil 9 as scheduled. There is no evidence-based rationale or safety data to support switching to Gardasil 4 (or any other HPV vaccine) after starting Gardasil 9.