Guidelines for Managing a Chest Tube in Patients with Pleural Effusion
Small bore chest tubes (10-14F) should be the initial choice for draining pleural effusions, as they are less traumatic to insert, more comfortable for patients, and have similar success rates to large bore tubes. 1
Chest Tube Selection and Insertion
Tube Size
- Small bore catheters (10-14F) are recommended as first-line for most pleural effusions 1, 2
- Large bore tubes (24-32F) may be considered in specific situations:
- Hemothorax
- Malignant effusions when immediate pleurodesis is planned
- After failure of small bore tubes in cases with very large air leaks 2
Insertion Technique
- Ultrasound guidance should be used for all thoracentesis and chest tube placements 3
- Reduces pneumothorax risk (1.0% vs 8.9% without guidance) 3
- Helps identify optimal insertion site
- Avoid trocar technique (dangerous and outdated) 2
- Use either:
- Seldinger technique for small bore tubes
- Blunt dissection for larger tubes (>24F) 2
- Insertion site should be determined by ultrasound to identify the optimal location 4, 1
- For malignant effusions, the tube should ideally be positioned at the paravertebral gutter in the posterobasal area for maximum drainage efficiency 5
Chest Tube Management
Initial Management
- Confirm proper tube position with chest radiograph after insertion 4, 1
- Connect tube to appropriate drainage system:
- Underwater seal
- Electronic drainage system
- Vacuum bottles (for indwelling pleural catheters) 2
- For malignant effusions, controlled evacuation is critical to prevent re-expansion pulmonary edema 1
Ongoing Management
- Maintain the drainage system below the level of the patient's chest at all times 4
- Monitor for:
- Fluid output (document amount and characteristics)
- Air leaks
- Tube position and patency 6
- Apply suction only if gravity drainage is ineffective 2
- For malignant effusions, maintain at 20cm H₂O suction after unclamping the chest tube 1
- If drainage suddenly stops:
Chemical Pleurodesis (for Malignant Effusions)
If pleurodesis is planned:
- Ensure complete lung expansion before proceeding
- Administer premedication (analgesia/sedation)
- Instill lidocaine (3mg/kg; maximum 250mg) into pleural space
- Follow with sclerosant of choice (talc slurry 4-5g in 50ml normal saline is common)
- Clamp tube for 1 hour and consider patient rotation for talc slurry
- Unclamp and maintain on suction 1
Chest Tube Removal Criteria
For non-malignant effusions:
For malignant effusions after pleurodesis:
For empyema or complicated parapneumonic effusions:
Complications and Management
Common Complications
- Pain (manage with appropriate analgesia) 4, 2
- Drain blockage (flush with sterile saline) 4, 7
- Accidental dislodgment (secure properly with commercial dressings) 2
Serious Complications
- Pneumothorax (can occur during insertion or after removal)
- Infection (maintain strict aseptic technique)
- Re-expansion pulmonary edema (prevent by controlled evacuation)
- Organ injury (avoid with image guidance) 2
Important Cautions
- Never clamp a bubbling chest tube (risk of tension pneumothorax) 4
- Immediately unclamp and seek medical advice if patient develops breathlessness or chest pain after clamping 4
- For persistent sepsis despite drainage and antibiotics, consider surgical referral 4
Special Considerations for Failed Drainage
If initial management fails:
- Obtain contrast-enhanced CT scan to evaluate for:
- Loculations
- Tube position
- Pleural thickening ("fibrinous peel") 7
- Consider intrapleural fibrinolytics for loculated effusions 4, 7
- For malignant effusions with trapped lung, consider indwelling pleural catheter rather than repeated pleurodesis attempts 1, 3
- Early discussion with thoracic surgeon for persistent sepsis or organized empyema 4