The Significance of HC/AC Ratio in Obstetric Ultrasound for Estimating Fetal Weight
The head circumference (HC) to abdominal circumference (AC) ratio is not an independent predictor of adverse pregnancy outcomes and should not be relied upon for estimating fetal weight (EFW) in modern obstetric practice. 1
Understanding HC/AC Ratio in Fetal Growth Assessment
Historical Context and Evolution
The HC/AC ratio was traditionally used to classify fetal growth restriction (FGR) as either symmetric or asymmetric:
- Historical perspective: In the past, the HC/AC ratio was thought to provide valuable information about the timing of pregnancy insult, etiology, and prognosis of FGR 1
- Normal ratio changes: The ratio naturally decreases throughout pregnancy, starting at approximately 1.18 at 17 weeks and decreasing to about 0.96 at 40 weeks 2
- Asymmetric vs. symmetric growth: An elevated HC/AC ratio (above the 95th percentile) was historically used to identify asymmetric growth restriction, suggesting "head-sparing" in cases of placental insufficiency 2
Current Evidence on HC/AC Ratio
Recent evidence has significantly changed our understanding of the HC/AC ratio's clinical utility:
- Not predictive of outcomes: More recent studies have shown that growth and developmental delays are similar in both symmetric and asymmetric growth-restricted preterm newborns 1
- Not an independent predictor: The HC/AC ratio is not an independent predictor of adverse pregnancy outcomes 1
- Limited clinical value: Current guidelines from the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine (SMFM) no longer recommend using HC/AC ratio for clinical decision-making in FGR management 1
Modern Approach to Estimating Fetal Weight
Superior Methods for EFW
Current evidence supports more comprehensive approaches to EFW:
- Multiple biometric indices: Formulas based on 3 or 4 fetal biometric indices are significantly more accurate in estimating fetal weights than formulas based on 1 or 2 indices alone 1
- Recommended parameters: Modern EFW calculations typically incorporate head circumference (HC), abdominal circumference (AC), and femur length (FL) 3
- Best prediction formula: One validated formula is log(EFW) = 5.084820 - 54.06633 × (AC/100)³ - 95.80076 × (AC/100)³ × log(AC/100) + 3.136370 × (HC/100), where EFW is in grams and AC and HC are in centimeters 3
Clinical Implications for FGR Detection
For identifying and managing FGR, current evidence supports:
- EFW percentile: EFW below the 3rd percentile is the strongest independent predictor of composite adverse perinatal outcomes 4
- AC measurement: An AC below the 10th percentile has similar diagnostic accuracy to EFW below the 10th percentile for predicting small for gestational age (SGA) 1
- Doppler studies: Abnormal umbilical artery Doppler indices predict adverse perinatal outcomes and should be incorporated into FGR assessment 1
Practical Application in Clinical Practice
When Evaluating Fetal Growth:
- Use comprehensive EFW formulas incorporating multiple biometric parameters (HC, AC, FL)
- Compare EFW to appropriate population-based reference charts
- Assess individual biometric parameters (particularly AC) rather than ratios
- Incorporate Doppler studies for suspected FGR cases
- Consider gestational age when interpreting results (early vs. late FGR have different clinical presentations)
Pitfalls to Avoid:
- Don't rely solely on HC/AC ratio for diagnosing or classifying FGR
- Avoid using single biometric measurements for EFW calculations
- Don't focus exclusively on EFW without evaluating individual biometric parameters
- Beware of technical factors that can affect measurement accuracy (image quality, equipment calibration, sonographer experience)
Conclusion
While the HC/AC ratio was historically used to classify FGR as symmetric or asymmetric, current evidence shows it has limited clinical value in modern obstetric practice. For accurate EFW and assessment of fetal growth, clinicians should use comprehensive formulas incorporating multiple biometric parameters and evaluate individual measurements rather than relying on the HC/AC ratio.