Management After Positive Panorama Test for Triploidy, Trisomy 18, or Trisomy 13
Diagnostic testing is absolutely necessary following a positive Panorama prenatal test for triploidy, trisomy 18, or trisomy 13, as NIPS is only a screening test and not diagnostic. 1
Understanding the Screening Result
- A positive Panorama test (NIPS) indicates an increased risk but is not a definitive diagnosis
- NIPS analyzes cell-free DNA primarily of placental origin, which may not always represent the true fetal genetic status 1
- Sources of potential discordant results include:
- Confined placental mosaicism (CPM)
- Unrecognized twin or vanishing twin
- Maternal chromosomal abnormalities
- Maternal malignancy
- Technical issues including low fetal fraction
- Statistical errors 1
Recommended Next Steps
1. Genetic Counseling
- Immediate referral for genetic counseling is essential for patients with screen-positive NIPS results 1
- The counselor should explain:
- The difference between screening and diagnostic tests
- The specific condition detected and its implications
- Available diagnostic options and their risks/benefits
2. Diagnostic Testing Options
For Trisomy 18:
- Amniocentesis is preferred over CVS due to higher reliability
- If CVS is performed, concordant results in both cytotrophoblast and mesenchymal core are highly reliable (100% definitive diagnosis rate) 2
For Trisomy 13:
- Amniocentesis is strongly recommended as the primary diagnostic test
- CVS has a 13.5% rate of mosaic results requiring follow-up amniocentesis 2
- Only 86.5% of cases achieve definitive diagnosis with CVS alone 2
For Triploidy:
- Amniocentesis is strongly recommended
- No cases of triploidy are typically born alive, making accurate diagnosis crucial for management decisions 3
- Low fetal fraction on NIPS may itself be an indicator of triploidy 4
3. Timing Considerations
- CVS can be performed earlier (11-13 weeks) but has limitations:
- Both CVS and NIPS analyze placental tissue, which may have the same genetic anomaly
- Mosaic results on CVS cannot confirm an affected fetus and require follow-up amniocentesis 1
- Amniocentesis (15-20 weeks) provides more definitive results but is performed later
Important Caveats
- Mosaic CVS results should never be considered confirmation of a positive NIPS result 1
- For trisomy 13 specifically, the likelihood of finding CVS mosaicism requiring amniocentesis is approximately 22% 5
- The positive predictive value (PPV) of NIPS varies by maternal age and specific condition, with higher PPV in women of advanced maternal age 6
- Natural outcomes for these conditions are poor:
- Triploidy: No live births in studied cases
- Trisomy 13: 33% live birth rate with maximum survival of 87 hours
- Trisomy 18: 13% live birth rate with very short postnatal survival 3
If Diagnostic Testing is Declined
If parents decline diagnostic testing:
- A detailed genetics consultation should be arranged at birth
- Physical examination by a clinical geneticist should be performed
- If abnormal features are observed, blood chromosome analysis is recommended 1
Remember that while NIPS technology has advanced significantly, it remains a screening test with inherent limitations, and diagnostic confirmation is essential for accurate prenatal counseling and management decisions.