Differential Diagnosis for Anisocoria (One Pupil Bigger Than the Other) in an Adult
Single Most Likely Diagnosis
- Physiological Anisocoria: This condition is characterized by a small, benign difference in pupil size that is constant in different lighting conditions. It is very common and often discovered incidentally.
Other Likely Diagnoses
- Iris Damage or Trauma: Previous eye injury or surgery can cause scarring or damage to the iris, leading to uneven pupil sizes.
- Pupil-Sparing Third Cranial Nerve Palsy: Although typically associated with other symptoms like ptosis and diplopia, a pupil-sparing third nerve palsy can present with anisocoria without these additional symptoms, especially if the cause is ischemic (e.g., diabetes).
- Adie's Tonic Pupil: A condition affecting the nerves of the eye, leading to a dilated pupil that reacts slowly to light. It often presents unilaterally and can be associated with diminished or absent deep tendon reflexes.
Do Not Miss Diagnoses
- Third Cranial Nerve Palsy with Compression: If caused by an aneurysm or tumor compressing the third cranial nerve, it can initially present with isolated anisocoria before other symptoms develop. Early detection is crucial for preventing serious complications.
- Horner's Syndrome: Characterized by miosis (small pupil), ptosis, and anhidrosis. Although it typically presents with a smaller pupil on the affected side, it's essential to consider in the differential due to its potential causes, including carotid artery dissection or stroke.
- Oculosympathetic Paresis (Horner Syndrome): Similar to the above but can sometimes be confused with anisocoria due to the relative difference in pupil sizes.
Rare Diagnoses
- Argyll Robertson Pupil: Pupils that constrict when focusing on a near object but do not react to light, often associated with neurosyphilis.
- Holmes-Adie Syndrome (with areflexia): While Adie's pupil is considered in the likely diagnoses, the full syndrome with areflexia is less common.
- Congenital Anisocoria: Present at birth, this condition can be due to various anomalies in the development of the iris or nerves controlling pupil size.