Influenza Vaccine Types: Live vs. Inactivated
The influenza (flu) vaccine is available in both inactivated and live attenuated forms, but the standard flu shot most people receive is an inactivated (killed) vaccine, not a live vaccine.
Types of Influenza Vaccines
There are two main types of influenza vaccines available:
The inactivated influenza vaccine contains killed virus particles that cannot cause infection 1
The live attenuated influenza vaccine contains live but weakened (attenuated) influenza viruses that are:
- Temperature-sensitive - limited in replication at normal body temperature
- Cold-adapted - able to replicate efficiently only at lower temperatures
- Attenuated - producing mild or no symptoms related to influenza infection 1
Key Differences Between Vaccine Types
Inactivated Influenza Vaccine (IIV)
- Administered via intramuscular injection 1
- Contains killed virus particles 1
- Approved for persons aged 6 months and older 1
- Can be given to people with chronic medical conditions 1
- Standard formulation for most people receiving flu vaccination 1
Live Attenuated Influenza Vaccine (LAIV)
- Administered via intranasal spray 1
- Contains live but weakened virus 1
- Approved only for healthy persons aged 2-49 years 1
- Cannot be given to people with certain medical conditions, including asthma, immunocompromised states, and pregnancy 1
- Recipients may shed vaccine virus for up to 2-7 days after vaccination 1
Restrictions on LAIV Use
The live attenuated vaccine should not be given to:
- Persons younger than 2 years or 50 years and older 1
- Persons with asthma, reactive airways disease, or other chronic disorders 1
- Immunocompromised individuals 1
- Pregnant women 1
- Children or adolescents receiving aspirin or salicylates 1
- Healthcare personnel who work with severely immunocompromised patients 1
- Solid organ transplant recipients 1
Efficacy Considerations
- Both vaccines stimulate an immune response, though through somewhat different mechanisms 2, 3
- Efficacy can vary by season, circulating strains, and recipient age 4
- In some studies, inactivated vaccines have shown higher efficacy than live attenuated vaccines in adults 4
- The live attenuated vaccine has shown good efficacy in children in some studies 2
Common Pitfalls and Caveats
- Many people incorrectly assume all flu vaccines are the same type
- The standard flu shot that most people receive is an inactivated vaccine, not a live vaccine 1
- Special consideration must be given when vaccinating immunocompromised patients or their close contacts, as LAIV is contraindicated for immunocompromised individuals 1
- Healthcare workers caring for immunocompromised patients should preferentially receive inactivated vaccine rather than LAIV 1
- If household contacts of immunocompromised individuals receive LAIV, good hand hygiene and minimizing contact with secretions should be emphasized 1