Rising Healthcare Costs and the Potential for Healthcare System Collapse
The current trajectory of healthcare costs, with premiums increasing faster than incomes, is creating an unsustainable system that could lead to significant disruption in healthcare access and delivery if not addressed through comprehensive reforms.
The Scope of the Healthcare Cost Crisis
- U.S. healthcare spending is projected to reach $4.3 trillion and account for 19.3% of the national gross domestic product by 2019, with growth in spending not accompanied by commensurate improvements in health outcomes despite expenditures far exceeding those of other countries 1
- Cancer care costs alone are estimated to increase from $125 billion in 2010 to $158 billion in 2020, representing one of the fastest growing components of healthcare costs 1
- The high cost of health insurance has a direct relationship with the number of uninsured Americans, with studies indicating that 164,000 to 300,000 people lose employer-paid health insurance if premiums increase by just 1% 1
Financial Impact on Patients and Families
- Healthcare expenditures are cited as a major cause of personal bankruptcy, with the term "financial toxicity" now used to describe the financial distress that accompanies serious medical treatment 1
- Even for insured patients, out-of-pocket expenses associated with treatment can be substantial and lead to:
- Patients experiencing high out-of-pocket costs report reducing spending on basic necessities like food and clothing 1
Widening Healthcare Disparities
- The increasing cost burden creates greater health disparities, which runs counter to key goals of healthcare reform 1
- Life expectancy disparities between the wealthiest and poorest Americans have reached 10-15 years 2
- Poor Americans have worse access to care than wealthy Americans, partly because many remain uninsured despite coverage expansions 2
- Rising premiums and cost sharing have undermined wage gains and driven many households into debt and bankruptcy 2
Drivers of Increasing Healthcare Costs
- Introduction of costly new drugs and technologies without proportional improvements in outcomes 1
- Technological advances in imaging, robotics for surgery, and therapeutic radiology contribute significantly to cost growth 1
- Approximately half of real healthcare expenditure growth can be attributed to medical technology 1
- Early adoption of new technologies without stringent evidence requirements for medical devices compared to drugs 1
- Unrealistic patient and family expectations that lead clinicians to offer services despite lack of supporting evidence of benefit 1
Systemic Issues Contributing to the Crisis
- Few healthcare providers measure actual costs for treating patients with specific medical conditions over a full cycle of care, or compare costs with outcomes 3
- Poor costing systems mean that effective and efficient providers go unrewarded, while inefficient ones have little incentive to improve 3
- Cost shifting to patients through high-deductible policies, larger copayments, and other mechanisms is becoming increasingly common 1
- The share of healthcare resources devoted to care of the wealthy has risen, exacerbating disparities 2
The Path Forward
- Recognition that patient-physician discussions regarding cost of care are an important component of high-quality care 1
- Development of educational and support tools for providers to promote effective communication about costs with patients 1
- Creation of resources to help educate patients about healthcare costs to guide decision-making regarding treatment options 1
- Implementation of new costing approaches that use patients and their conditions as the fundamental unit of analysis for measuring costs and outcomes 3
- Additional reforms that move forward from the Affordable Care Act to mitigate health and healthcare inequalities 2
The evidence strongly suggests that without significant intervention, the healthcare system faces a potential breaking point where costs become prohibitive for an increasing number of Americans, leading to widespread access issues, poorer health outcomes, and potentially systemic collapse of parts of the healthcare delivery system 4, 2.