Metoprolol (Toprol) Has the Highest Likelihood of Causing Insomnia
Among the four medications listed, metoprolol (Toprol) carries the highest risk of insomnia, while Eliquis, Entresto, and Lasix have minimal to no association with sleep disturbance.
Evidence for Beta-Blocker-Associated Insomnia
Metoprolol's CNS Effects
- Metoprolol is a lipophilic beta-blocker that readily crosses the blood-brain barrier, causing CNS side effects including sleep disturbances, nightmares, bizarre dreams, and insomnia 1, 2.
- In a randomized double-blind crossover study, metoprolol caused significant increases in sleep disturbance (p < 0.01) and restless nights (p < 0.05) compared to atenolol, a less lipophilic beta-blocker 2.
- A large retrospective cohort study of 4,063 elderly hypertensive patients found that selective β1-blockers with low lipophilicity had 52% lower odds of insomnia compared to non-selective, highly lipophilic agents 3.
Mechanism of Sleep Disruption
- The risk of beta-blocker CNS side effects is directly associated with the drug's lipophilic properties, which determine brain penetration 1, 3.
- Common neuropsychiatric symptoms include psychiatric conditions, bizarre and vivid dreams, sleep disturbances, delirium, and visual hallucinations, particularly in elderly patients 1.
Other Medications in Question
Eliquis (Apixaban)
- No evidence links apixaban to insomnia as a side effect - this anticoagulant does not have CNS-penetrating properties that would affect sleep architecture.
Entresto (Sacubitril/Valsartan)
- No association with insomnia has been reported in clinical trials or post-marketing surveillance 4.
- The PARADIGM-HF trial, which enrolled thousands of heart failure patients, did not identify sleep disturbance as an adverse effect of sacubitril/valsartan 4.
Lasix (Furosemide)
- Furosemide does not cause insomnia directly, though nocturia from diuresis can indirectly disrupt sleep if dosed too late in the day.
- The mechanism is purely peripheral (renal tubular effects) without CNS penetration.
Clinical Implications
Risk Stratification
- Elderly patients started on metoprolol require close monitoring for neurological symptoms including insomnia 1.
- Patients reporting sleep disturbances on metoprolol should be evaluated for medication-related causes before pursuing other insomnia treatments 2.
Management Strategy
- If insomnia develops on metoprolol, consider switching to a less lipophilic beta-blocker (such as atenolol or bisoprolol) which have 69% and 53% lower odds of insomnia, respectively 3.
- Discontinuation of lipophilic beta-blockers produces significant improvement in quality of sleep, dreams, concentration, and energy 2.