What is end-tidal carbon dioxide (ET CO2) and how is fogging in ventilation managed?

End-Tidal Carbon Dioxide (ETCO2) and Fogging in Ventilation

What is End-Tidal Carbon Dioxide (ETCO2)?

ETCO2 is the partial pressure of carbon dioxide measured at the end of exhalation, typically 35-40 mmHg in healthy individuals, and serves as a critical real-time monitor of ventilation, cardiac output, and metabolic status. 1

Physiologic Determinants

ETCO2 reflects three primary physiologic processes:

• CO2 production from cellular metabolism 1
• Alveolar ventilation (minute ventilation and dead space) 1
• Pulmonary blood flow (cardiac output during low-flow states) 1

During mechanical ventilation with relatively fixed minute ventilation, pulmonary blood flow becomes the primary determinant of ETCO2 values. 1

Clinical Measurement

• Waveform capnography is the gold standard for ETCO2 measurement, as visualization of the actual CO2 waveform ensures accuracy and confirms proper endotracheal tube placement. 1, 2
• Continuous waveform capnography is recommended as the most reliable method for confirming and monitoring correct ETT position (Class I, LOE C-LD). 1, 2
• ETCO2 measurement requires control during specialized procedures like ventilatory endurance testing, usually by adjusting the CO2 fraction in the rebreathing dead space. 1

Normal Values and Interpretation

• Normal ETCO2 range: 35-40 mmHg 3
• Values >50 mmHg indicate hypoventilation and potential respiratory compromise 4
• Values <30 mmHg indicate significant hyperventilation 3
• Absolute change from baseline >10 mmHg is clinically significant and may indicate respiratory depression before oxygen desaturation occurs 4

Clinical Applications in Mechanical Ventilation

During cardiac arrest and CPR:

• If PETCO2 <10 mmHg during CPR, immediately attempt to improve chest compression quality. 1
• ETCO2 levels reflect cardiac output generated by chest compressions during low-flow states. 1

For ventilated patients:

• ETCO2 monitoring can detect hypoventilation before clinical signs become apparent. 4
• An increase in ETCO2 might be the only early clue to potential respiratory compromise. 4

Important Limitations in Critically Ill Patients

ETCO2 accuracy is significantly compromised in certain clinical scenarios:

• Trauma patients: ETCO2 has poor correlation with PaCO2 (R² = 0.277) and should not be used to guide ventilation in intubated trauma patients. 5 Patients ventilated to recommended ETCO2 ranges (35-40 mmHg) were under-ventilated (PaCO2 >40 mmHg) 80% of the time. 5

• Post-cardiac surgery patients: While correlation between ETCO2 and PaCO2 exists (r = 0.671-0.727), ETCO2 measurements cannot replace serial blood gas analyses. 6

• Critically ill patients with V/Q mismatch: The PaCO2-ETCO2 gradient is inconstant during ventilator changes, and trends in ETCO2 may move in the opposite direction from PaCO2 in some patients. 7

• Non-intubated patients: ETCO2 from bag-mask ventilation or supraglottic airways may not consistently reflect true values, making measurement less reliable for prognostication. 1

Technical factors causing falsely low ETCO2:

• Bronchospasm or mucous plugging of the ETT 1
• Kinking of the ETT 1
• Alveolar fluid in the ETT 1
• Hyperventilation 1
• Air leak in the airway 1
• Mouth breathing or nasal cannula occlusion 4

Monitoring During Intrahospital Transport

ETCO2 monitoring is abbreviated as "ETCO2" in critical care transport protocols and should be continuously monitored during patient movement. 1

---

Fogging in Ventilation

"Fogging" refers to the visual condensation of water vapor that appears inside the endotracheal tube or ventilator circuit during exhalation, serving as a basic clinical indicator of gas exchange and tube patency, though it is not a reliable method for confirming proper tube placement.

Clinical Significance

While fogging provides a crude visual confirmation that gas is moving through the tube:

• Fogging alone is insufficient to confirm proper endotracheal tube placement 2
• Waveform capnography remains the gold standard for ETT placement confirmation (Class I, LOE C-LD) 1, 2
• If waveform capnography is unavailable, alternatives include nonwaveform CO2 detectors, esophageal detector devices, and ultrasound by experienced operators (Class IIa, LOE C-LD) 2

Equipment Considerations

Proper humidification of inspired air is necessary during ventilatory procedures to prevent excessive condensation while maintaining adequate moisture. 1 The ventilation system should provide reasonable humidification without creating excessive fogging that could obstruct visualization or impair monitoring. 1

Post-Intubation Verification Protocol

After securing the ETT:

1. Confirm placement with waveform capnography 2
2. Perform clinical assessment 2
3. Record tube depth at front teeth or gums 2
4. Obtain chest x-ray when feasible to confirm positioning above the carina 2
5. Continue monitoring with waveform capnography to detect displacement 2