Is a right knee MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) medically necessary for a 69-year-old male with persistent right knee pain and a history of tremors, possible Parkinson's disease, and no prior imaging or treatments?

Right Knee MRI is NOT Medically Necessary at This Time

The requested right knee MRI (CPT 73721) is not medically indicated because the patient has not completed the required prerequisite steps: no plain radiographs have been obtained, and no conservative treatments have been documented or attempted.

Algorithmic Approach to Knee MRI Authorization

Step 1: Initial Imaging Must Be Completed First

• Plain radiographs of the knee are the mandatory first imaging study for chronic knee pain and must include frontal projection, tangential patellar view, and lateral view 1.
• The American College of Radiology explicitly states that radiography is "usually appropriate for the initial imaging of chronic knee pain" in patients ≥5 years of age 1.
• Approximately 20% of patients with chronic knee pain inappropriately undergo MRI without recent radiographs—this is identified as a common pitfall to avoid 2.
• In this case, no radiographs have been documented, making MRI premature.

Step 2: Conservative Treatment Must Be Attempted and Failed

The MCG criteria correctly identify that for chronic knee pain of ≥6 weeks duration, MRI is indicated only when ALL of the following are met 1:

• Pain of 6+ weeks duration (✓ MET: "many months")
• Pain unexplained by history and physical examination with normal findings on plain x-ray (✗ NOT MET: no x-rays performed)
• Pain unresponsive to appropriate conservative measures such as NSAIDs, physical therapy, or rest (✗ NOT MET: no treatments documented)

Step 3: When MRI Becomes Appropriate

MRI without IV contrast is indicated only after radiographs are obtained and one of these conditions exists 1:

• Initial radiographs are normal or show only joint effusion, AND conservative treatment has failed
• Radiographs demonstrate specific findings (OCD, loose bodies, prior cartilage/meniscal repair, signs of prior osseous injury)
• Surgery is being considered 3

Critical Missing Documentation

What Is Required Before MRI Authorization:

1. Plain knee radiographs (3 views minimum) 1
2. Documentation of conservative treatment attempts, including:
   • NSAIDs trial with duration and response 1
   • Physical therapy referral/completion 1
   • Rest period with activity modification 1
3. Physical examination findings specific to the knee, including:
   • Presence/absence of effusion 1
   • Range of motion limitations 1
   • Ligamentous stability testing 1
   • Specific pain localization and provocative maneuvers 1

What the Current Documentation Shows:

• Physical exam states only "normal extremity with no clubbing, cyanosis or edema" [@case documentation]
• No knee-specific examination findings documented (no effusion assessment, no ligamentous testing, no range of motion) [@case documentation]
• No prior imaging of any kind [@case documentation]
• No conservative treatments documented [@case documentation]

Important Clinical Considerations

Referred Pain Must Be Excluded First

• The American College of Radiology emphasizes that referred pain from the hip or lumbar spine must be considered before attributing symptoms to knee pathology 2, 4.
• This is particularly relevant given the patient's neurological symptoms (tremors, possible Parkinson's disease) 2, 4.
• A thorough clinical examination including lumbar spine and hip assessment should be completed before imaging 2, 4.

Age-Related Imaging Limitations

• In patients >70 years of age, bilateral structural abnormalities can be present with primarily unilateral symptoms, limiting MRI's ability to discriminate painful from nonpainful knees 1, 2.
• This 69-year-old patient is approaching this age threshold where MRI findings may not correlate with symptoms 1, 2.

Recommendation for Authorization

DENY the right knee MRI at this time. Require the following before resubmission:

1. Obtain plain radiographs of the right knee (frontal, lateral, and tangential patellar views) 1
2. Document a minimum 6-week trial of conservative treatment including at least two of: NSAIDs, physical therapy, activity modification 1
3. Perform and document a comprehensive knee-specific physical examination including effusion assessment, range of motion, ligamentous stability, and provocative maneuvers 1
4. Evaluate for referred pain sources including hip and lumbar spine examination 2, 4

If radiographs are normal or show only effusion AND conservative treatment fails AND knee-specific pathology is confirmed on examination, then MRI becomes appropriate 1.

---

Note regarding the Brain MRI (CPT 70551): The brain MRI for evaluation of tremor and possible Parkinson's disease appears to meet MCG criteria for new onset symptoms suggestive of neurodegenerative disorder and can be certified separately 5, 6.