Features Suggesting Discordance Between Imaging and Pathology
Discordance exists when benign pathology results do not match suspicious imaging characteristics, such as a negative fine needle aspiration associated with a spiculated BI-RADS category 5 mass. 1, 2
Key Features Indicating Discordance
Imaging-Pathology Mismatch Patterns
The most critical discordance pattern is benign pathology obtained from highly suspicious imaging findings (BI-RADS 4-5 lesions). 1, 2 This represents the classic scenario where imaging characteristics strongly suggest malignancy but the biopsy yields benign results.
Specific examples of discordance include:
- Negative or benign biopsy from a spiculated mass (BI-RADS 5), which is highly suggestive of malignancy on imaging 1, 2
- Benign pathology from lesions with suspicious microcalcifications showing fine pleomorphic or fine-linear branching patterns 3
- Benign results from masses with irregular margins or architectural distortion that appear suspicious on mammography or ultrasound 1, 2
Technical Factors Contributing to Discordance
Inadequate tissue sampling is a major cause of discordance, occurring when the lesion is missed or only partially sampled during biopsy. 4
Technical issues include:
- Missed lesions - the biopsy needle completely misses the target lesion (44% of discordant malignant lesions in one study) 4
- Partial sampling - only the periphery of the lesion is sampled, missing the malignant component (44-48% of discordant cases) 4
- Geographic non-correlation - the biopsied area does not correspond to the imaging abnormality 1
Clinical and Imaging Characteristics
Discordance rates range from 1.9% to 5.8% across different biopsy techniques and institutions. 5, 6, 7, 4, 8 The malignancy rate in discordant cases is substantial, ranging from 27.5% to 36%, underscoring the critical importance of recognizing discordance. 4, 8
Specific imaging features that should raise concern for discordance when paired with benign pathology:
- BI-RADS 4C or 5 lesions (50-95% risk of malignancy) with benign biopsy results 9
- Spiculated or irregular masses with benign pathology 1, 2
- Suspicious calcifications (fine pleomorphic, fine-linear branching) with benign results 3
- Solid masses with suspicious ultrasound features (irregular margins, posterior shadowing, taller-than-wide orientation) yielding benign pathology 2
Management Algorithm for Discordance
Immediate Actions Required
When discordance is identified, breast imaging should be repeated and additional tissue sampled or excised; surgical excision is recommended if pathology and imaging remain discordant. 1, 2
The management pathway:
- Repeat imaging to confirm the lesion characteristics and ensure the biopsy targeted the correct area 1, 2
- Obtain additional tissue sampling through repeat core needle biopsy or surgical excision 1, 2
- Proceed directly to surgical excision if discordance persists after repeat biopsy 1, 2
Multidisciplinary Review
Implementation of radiologic-pathologic correlation conferences significantly reduces discordance rates (from 8.8% to 2%) and false-negative rates (from 29.3% to 4%). 6
These conferences should:
- Review all benign biopsies from BI-RADS 4-5 lesions to identify potential discordance 5, 6, 7
- Include radiologists, pathologists, and surgeons to reach consensus on concordance 5, 6, 7
- Document the rationale for concordance or discordance determination 5, 6
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
Never accept benign pathology at face value for highly suspicious imaging findings without confirming concordance. 1, 2 The false-negative rate for discordant cases can be as high as 29.3% without proper multidisciplinary review. 6
Critical errors include:
- Failing to compare biopsy results with the original imaging characteristics before finalizing management 1, 2
- Assuming adequate sampling occurred without reviewing post-biopsy imaging to confirm lesion targeting 4
- Delaying surgical excision when clear discordance exists, as 27.5-36% of discordant cases harbor malignancy 4, 8
- Not obtaining post-biopsy imaging to verify the biopsy site corresponds to the imaging abnormality 4
For indeterminate or borderline cases, err on the side of surgical excision rather than observation, given the substantial malignancy rate in discordant lesions. 4, 8