Approach to Assessment of Behavioral Concerns

Definition

Behavioral concerns encompass any actions or patterns that affect health, functioning, or well-being, arising from biological, psychological, and socio-cultural factors that vary across contexts such as home, school, and peer interactions. 1

Classification

By Context of Manifestation

Context-specific behaviors: Concerns displayed only at home, only at school, or only in peer interactions 1
Cross-contextual behaviors: Concerns pervasive across multiple settings 1

By Function

Escape/avoidance behaviors: Actions serving to avoid demands or aversive situations 1
Attention-seeking behaviors: Actions maintained by social attention 1
Access-seeking behaviors: Actions to gain preferred items or people 1
Self-regulatory behaviors: Internal reinforcement such as self-stimulation or pain reduction 1

By Presentation Type

Externalizing behaviors: Disruptive, aggressive, hyperactive, or oppositional actions 1
Internalizing behaviors: Anxiety, depression, social withdrawal, or body image concerns 1

Differential Diagnosis

Primary Psychiatric Disorders

Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): Contextual variations in attention and hyperactivity 1
Oppositional defiant disorder (ODD): Disruptive behavior with authority figures 1
Conduct disorder: Rule-breaking and aggressive behaviors 1
Social anxiety disorder: Social competence deficits and avoidance 1
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD): Preoccupation with perceived appearance flaws 1
Depression: Dysphoric mood, irritability, behavioral withdrawal 1
Bipolar disorder: Manic/hypomanic episodes presenting as behavioral dysregulation 2

Medical Contributors

Seizure disorders: Post-ictal behavioral symptoms 1
Sensory impairments: Hearing or visual deficits causing anxiety and challenging behaviors 1
Motor impairments: Cerebral palsy or spina bifida associated with inattention and hyperactivity 1
Pain or physical discomfort: Dental problems, constipation, headaches, ear infections presenting as behavioral problems 1, 3
Medication side effects: Stimulants, antiepileptics, antipsychotics, muscle relaxants causing behavioral dysregulation 1, 4

Environmental and Psychosocial Factors

Trauma and abuse: Victimization leading to behavioral manifestations 4
Environmental changes: Transitions in school, residence, caregivers, or routine 1, 3
Inappropriate demands: Educational or home demands exceeding cognitive abilities 1, 3
Communication deficits: Limited ability to express needs verbally or through alternative methods 1, 3
Caregiver stress: Exhaustion or psychopathology in caregivers triggering behavioral symptoms 4, 3

History

Character of Behavioral Concerns

Onset and duration: When behaviors started, acute versus gradual onset, episodic versus continuous 1
Frequency and intensity: How often behaviors occur and severity of episodes 5
Contextual patterns: Specific settings where behaviors manifest (home only, school only, pervasive) 1
Antecedents: Events, situations, or triggers immediately preceding the behavior 1, 5, 6
Consequences: What happens after the behavior (attention, escape, access to items) 1, 5
Conditions when behavior does NOT occur: Protective contexts or situations 6

Multi-Informant Assessment

Parent report: Behaviors observed at home and in family interactions 1
Teacher report: Behaviors in school setting and with non-parental authority figures 1
Self-report: Patient's own perspective on concerns, thoughts, and distress 1
Collateral information: Reports from other caregivers, coaches, or peers 7
Discrepancy interpretation: Differences between informants may reflect true contextual variations rather than measurement error 1

Red Flags Requiring Immediate Attention

Suicidal ideation: Both active and passive thoughts, past attempts, access to lethal means 7, 2
Homicidal ideation: Thoughts of harming others with plan or intent 7
Self-injurious behaviors: Cutting, burning, head-banging, or other self-harm 1
Acute behavioral escalation: Sudden worsening or new-onset aggressive behaviors 1
Psychotic symptoms: Hallucinations, delusions, disorganized thinking 7
Altered mental status: Confusion, disorientation, or cognitive changes 7
Medication-induced symptoms: Agitation, akathisia, hypomania, or mania on antidepressants 2

Risk Factors

Developmental factors: Intellectual disability, autism spectrum disorder, developmental delays 1, 4, 3
Family history: Suicide, bipolar disorder, depression, or other psychiatric disorders 1, 2
Trauma exposure: Physical, sexual, or emotional abuse; neglect; witnessing violence 4
Social factors: Peer rejection, bullying, social isolation 1
Environmental stressors: Poverty, high-crime neighborhoods, family conflict 1
Comorbid conditions: Multiple psychiatric diagnoses, medical complexity 1
Sociocultural pressures: Media influence, appearance-focused culture (for BDD) 1

Developmental and Family History

Developmental milestones: Language, motor, social, and cognitive development 1
Educational history: Academic performance, special education services, school transitions 1
Medical history: Chronic illnesses, hospitalizations, medications, seizures 1
Family psychiatric history: Mental health disorders in first-degree relatives 1, 2
Family accommodation: Parental behaviors that inadvertently reinforce concerns (reassurance-seeking, avoidance facilitation) 1

Physical Examination (Focused)

General Observations During Assessment

Appearance clues: Wearing hats, hoods, or sunglasses indoors; heavy or unusual makeup; frequent mirror-checking or phone use (for BDD) 1
Behavioral observations: Eye contact, cooperation, interaction style with examiner versus parent 1
Speech patterns: Rate, volume, coherence, spontaneity 7
Motor activity: Restlessness, fidgeting, psychomotor agitation or retardation 7

Mental Status Examination

Appearance and behavior: Grooming, dress, posture, level of distress 7
Mood and affect: Subjective mood state and observed emotional expression 7
Thought process: Linear, tangential, circumstantial, or disorganized 7
Thought content: Preoccupations, obsessions, delusions, suicidal or homicidal ideation 7
Perception: Hallucinations (auditory, visual, tactile) 7
Cognition: Orientation, attention, memory, executive function 7
Insight and judgment: Awareness of problems and decision-making capacity 7

Targeted Physical Findings

Vital signs: Abnormalities suggesting medical etiology or medication effects 7
Neurological examination: Focal deficits, seizure stigmata, movement disorders 1
Sensory assessment: Hearing and vision screening 1
Signs of self-harm: Cuts, burns, bruises in various stages of healing 1
Signs of abuse or neglect: Unexplained injuries, poor hygiene, malnutrition 4

Investigations and Expected Findings

Screening and Assessment Tools

Depression screening: PHQ-9 (cutoff ≥8) or PHQ-2 (full assessment if either item ≥2) 7
Cognitive assessment: Mini-Cog (76% sensitivity, 89% specificity), MoCA, or SLUMS adjusted for education and language 7
Adaptive functioning: Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales or ABAS-II for conceptual, social, and practical skills 1
Intellectual assessment: Age-appropriate IQ testing when developmental concerns present 1
BDD-specific assessment: Systematic inquiry about appearance concerns across body areas 1

Functional Behavioral Assessment

Setting events: Broader contextual factors (sleep deprivation, hunger, illness) 1, 5
Immediate antecedents: Specific triggers occurring seconds to minutes before behavior 1, 5, 6
Behavior description: Operational definition of target behavior (observable, measurable) 5, 6
Consequences: What happens immediately after behavior (attention, escape, tangible items) 1, 5
Function identification: Escape, attention, access, or sensory reinforcement 1, 5

Contextually Sensitive Independent Measures

Structured behavioral observations: Disruptive Behavior Diagnostic Observation Schedule (DB-DOS) assessing behavior with parental versus non-parental adults 1
Social interaction tasks: Laboratory assessments across varying contexts (one-on-one versus public speaking) 1
Physiological monitoring: Wireless heart rate monitors to assess arousal patterns across contexts 1
Social network analysis: Peer interaction patterns and social competence 1

Laboratory and Medical Workup

Indicated only when: Altered mental status, unexplained vital sign abnormalities, new-onset or acute psychiatric changes 7
Not routine: Avoid blanket laboratory testing without clinical indication 7
Specific tests based on presentation: Thyroid function, metabolic panel, toxicology screen, neuroimaging only when history and exam suggest medical etiology 7

Expected Findings by Diagnosis

Context-specific ODD: Parent reports disruptive behavior, teacher does not (or vice versa); DB-DOS shows disruptive behavior only with parental adults 1
Cross-contextual ADHD: Both parent and teacher report attention/hyperactivity concerns; pervasive across structured observations 1
Social anxiety: Elevated physiological arousal during social tasks despite behavioral habituation; self-report of persistent high arousal 1
BDD: Preoccupation with specific body areas, repetitive behaviors (mirror-checking, reassurance-seeking), significant distress and impairment 1

Empiric Treatment

First-Line: Behavioral Interventions

Behavioral interventions must be attempted before medication for behavioral concerns, as psychotropic medications should never substitute for appropriate services. 1, 4

Function-based interventions: Tailor strategies to identified reinforcement pattern (escape, attention, access, sensory) 1, 4, 5
Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA): Evidence-based for problem behaviors, social skills, and adaptive living skills in intellectual disabilities 4, 3
Antecedent modification: Alter triggers or setting events to prevent behavior occurrence 1, 5
Replacement behavior training: Teach functionally equivalent appropriate behaviors 4, 3
Consequence management: Reinforce desired behaviors, minimize reinforcement of problem behaviors 1, 5

Psychoeducation and Skills Training

Socio-sexual education: For hypersexual behaviors, teach appropriate versus inappropriate expression, privacy, consent, boundaries (developmental level-appropriate) 4
Social skills training: Explicit teaching of pragmatic language and social reciprocity 3
Communication support: Implement augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) for individuals with limited verbal abilities 1, 3
Caregiver training: Educate parents and staff on trigger recognition, consistent behavioral strategies, appropriate redirection 4, 3

Environmental Modifications

Demand-ability matching: Ensure educational and home demands align with cognitive abilities 1, 3
Routine and structure: Embed predictable schedules to reduce anxiety from transitions 3
Safety modifications: Implement environmental supports (grab rails, sensor lights) when indicated 3
Reduce environmental stressors: Address changes in residence, school, or caregivers 1, 3

Pharmacological Treatment (Second-Line)

Medication should only be considered when behavioral interventions have failed, when there is risk of harm to self or others, or when the individual risks losing access to essential services. 1, 4

For Hypersexual Behavior or Impulse Control Issues

Sertraline: Start 25-50mg daily, titrate slowly due to heightened sensitivity in intellectual disabilities 4
Alternative SSRIs: Fluoxetine if sertraline not tolerated, using "start low, go slow" principle 4
Monitoring: Watch for activation symptoms (agitation, akathisia, hypomania, mania) especially in first weeks 2

For Underlying Psychiatric Disorders

Treat diagnosed DSM-5 disorder: Medication selection proceeds from specific psychiatric diagnosis, not behavioral symptoms alone 1, 3
Comprehensive treatment plan: Medication as part of multimodal approach including behavioral interventions 1, 3

SSRI Safety Considerations

Suicide risk monitoring: Increased risk of suicidal thinking in children, adolescents, and young adults (ages <24) during initial treatment 2
Close observation: Monitor weekly during first month, then biweekly for second month, then at 12 weeks and as clinically indicated 2
Warning signs: Agitation, panic attacks, insomnia, irritability, hostility, impulsivity, akathisia, hypomania, mania 2
Bipolar screening: Screen for bipolar disorder risk before initiating antidepressants (family history of bipolar, suicide, depression) 2
Smallest quantity prescriptions: Write for limited supply to reduce overdose risk 2

Indications to Refer

Immediate Referral (Emergency Department or Crisis Services)

Active suicidal ideation with plan or intent 7, 2
Homicidal ideation with plan or intent 7
Acute psychosis with safety concerns 7
Severe self-injurious behavior requiring medical attention 1
Acute behavioral crisis with risk of harm 1

Urgent Referral (Within Days)

Suicidal ideation without immediate plan but with risk factors 7, 2
New-onset psychiatric symptoms with functional impairment 1
Medication-induced activation symptoms (agitation, akathisia, hypomania) 2
Suspected abuse or neglect requiring protective services 4

Routine Specialty Referral

Psychiatry specializing in intellectual disabilities: Treatment-refractory cases, complex medication management 4, 3
Developmental-behavioral pediatrics: Comprehensive assessment of medical, developmental, and behavioral factors 4
Psychology: Formal cognitive testing, adaptive behavior assessment, evidence-based psychotherapy 1, 3
Behavior analyst (BCBA): Functional behavioral assessment and ABA intervention design 1, 4
Speech-language pathology: Communication assessment and AAC implementation 1, 3
Occupational therapy: Sensory processing, motor skills, daily living skills assessment 1, 3
Social work/case management: Environmental assessment, resource coordination, caregiver support 1, 3

Multidisciplinary Team Approach

Complex behavioral concerns require coordinated care across multiple disciplines to address biopsychosocial factors. 4, 3

Regular team communication: Ensure goals and needs are being met, reflect changes in diagnosis or prognosis 3
Specialized treatment settings: Preliminary evidence for improved outcomes in specialized intellectual disability programs 4, 3

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

Assessment Pitfalls

Dismissing appearance concerns as "normal adolescence": BDD is under-detected because clinicians minimize symptoms; directly ask about appearance preoccupations 1
Failing to obtain multi-informant reports: Relying on single informant misses contextual variations in behavior 1
Misinterpreting informant discrepancies as measurement error: Differences between parent and teacher reports often reflect true context-specific behaviors, not unreliable reporting 1
Using chronological age instead of developmental age: Compare behaviors to developmental level, not chronological age, especially in intellectual disabilities 1, 4, 3, 7
Overlooking medical contributors: Pain, constipation, dental problems, ear infections, seizures may present as behavioral problems in individuals with limited communication 1, 3
Ignoring medication side effects: Stimulants, antipsychotics, antiepileptics can cause behavioral dysregulation 1, 4
Inadequate suicide risk assessment: Never dismiss suicidal thoughts as unimportant; assess active and passive ideation, past attempts, access to means 7, 2
Failing to screen for bipolar disorder before starting antidepressants: Antidepressants may precipitate manic episodes in at-risk individuals 2

Treatment Pitfalls

Prescribing medication without behavioral interventions first: Violates evidence-based guidelines and exposes patients to unnecessary medication risks 1, 4
Using psychotropic medications as substitute for appropriate services: Medication should never replace behavioral, educational, or environmental interventions 1, 4, 3
Treating behavior in isolation without assessing underlying causes: Always evaluate for psychiatric disorders, medical conditions, environmental stressors, trauma 1, 4, 3
Providing reassurance about appearance in BDD: Reassurance fuels counterproductive cycle and is interpreted as dismissive 1
Facilitating family accommodation: Parents inadvertently reinforce behavioral concerns through excessive reassurance, avoidance facilitation, or purchasing excessive cosmetic products 1
Ignoring caregiver stress and burnout: Caregiver exhaustion or psychopathology can trigger or exacerbate behavioral symptoms 4, 3
Inadequate monitoring during SSRI initiation: Failure to closely observe for suicidality and activation symptoms in first 8-12 weeks 2
Abrupt medication discontinuation: Taper antidepressants to avoid discontinuation syndrome 2

Diagnostic Pitfalls

Pathologizing developmentally appropriate behavior: Normal adolescent self-consciousness differs from BDD; normal oppositional behavior differs from ODD 1, 7
Misdiagnosis due to symptom overlap: BDD often misdiagnosed as depression or social anxiety when appearance concerns not directly assessed 1
Attributing all behaviors to primary diagnosis: In intellectual disabilities, new behavioral symptoms may indicate comorbid psychiatric disorder, not just the underlying developmental condition 1, 3
Relying solely on screening scores without clinical context: Screening tools require interpretation considering education, language, culture, and clinical presentation 7

What is the approach to assessing behavioral concerns?

Help us tailor your experience