Differential Diagnosis for Septic Bursitis of the Elbow
The differential diagnosis for septic olecranon bursitis primarily includes non-septic (aseptic) olecranon bursitis, cellulitis, abscess, septic arthritis of the elbow joint, osteomyelitis, gout, and pseudogout.
Primary Differential Considerations
Non-Septic (Aseptic) Olecranon Bursitis
- Traumatic or inflammatory bursitis is the most common alternative diagnosis, often resulting from repetitive trauma or pressure on the elbow 1
- Physical activities associated with increased mechanical stress distinguish this from infectious causes 1
- Bursal fluid analysis typically shows lower white blood cell counts (<3000 cells/mm³) without bacteria 2
Cellulitis
- Superficial skin infection can mimic septic bursitis with erythema, warmth, and swelling 1
- Distinguished by lack of discrete fluctuant collection and absence of bursal fluid on aspiration 2
- May coexist with septic bursitis, complicating diagnosis 1
Septic Arthritis of the Elbow Joint
- Intra-articular infection presents with severe pain, restricted range of motion, and joint effusion 3
- Requires joint aspiration rather than bursal aspiration for diagnosis 3
- More severe systemic symptoms and functional impairment than isolated bursitis 1
Abscess Formation
- Subcutaneous or deep soft tissue abscess may present similarly with fluctuance and erythema 1
- Imaging (ultrasound or MRI) helps distinguish location and extent 3
Microbiological Differential
Typical Bacterial Pathogens
- Staphylococcus aureus causes >80% of septic bursitis cases 1
- Other gram-positive organisms (Streptococcus species, Staphylococcus epidermidis) account for most remaining cases 1, 4
Atypical Pathogens
- Mycobacterium gordonae and other atypical mycobacteria cause rare cases with insidious onset and delayed diagnosis 5
- Gram-negative organisms, fungi, and other infectious agents represent uncommon causes requiring specialized testing 1
- PCR and extended culture periods may be necessary for identification 5
Crystal Arthropathy Differential
Gout and Pseudogout
- Crystal-induced bursitis can present with acute inflammation mimicking infection 1
- Bursal fluid analysis with polarized microscopy distinguishes crystals from infection 2
- May coexist with septic bursitis in immunocompromised patients 1
Osteomyelitis
- Underlying bone infection of the olecranon may extend to involve the bursa 3
- MRI with gadolinium is the imaging modality of choice for detection 3
- Requires longer antibiotic duration (minimum 8 weeks) compared to isolated bursitis 3
Key Diagnostic Pitfalls
Bursal aspiration with synovial fluid analysis is essential to differentiate septic from non-septic causes 2. Fluid should be sent for:
- Cell count and differential (>3000 cells/mm³ suggests infection) 2
- Gram stain and bacterial culture 1
- Crystal analysis to exclude gout/pseudogout 1
- Consider PCR if atypical mycobacteria suspected 5
Systemic conditions increase severity and complicate diagnosis, including immunocompromised states, diabetes, chronic kidney disease, and chronic corticosteroid use 1. These patients warrant lower threshold for hospitalization and parenteral antibiotics 1.