Is a C2-C7 anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) with pedicle screw, cage, allograft (bone graft), autograft (bone graft), and bone marrow aspirate indicated for a patient with advanced cervical disc degeneration, significant arthritis, and degenerative changes, who has failed nonoperative treatment and experiences severe neck pain and stiffness?

Medical Necessity Determination for C2-C7 ACDF

Direct Answer: This Procedure is NOT Medically Necessary as Currently Documented

The proposed C2-C7 ACDF cannot be approved because critical documentation is missing: there is no physical examination documenting objective neurologic deficits, no documentation of the duration of conservative treatment failure (only that injections provided relief), and the patient lacks radicular arm symptoms despite multilevel disease. 1

---

Critical Missing Documentation Elements

Absence of Objective Neurologic Examination

• The American College of Surgeons requires documented progressive neurologic deficits, significant radicular pain affecting function, or myelopathic symptoms on physical examination to establish medical necessity for ACDF. 1
• The absence of objective neurologic deficits on examination is a critical contraindication for surgical intervention, as ACDF is primarily indicated when conservative management fails to prevent progressive neurologic deterioration. 1
• The patient reports no arm symptoms such as tingling, which contradicts the indication for cervical radiculopathy requiring multilevel fusion. 2

Inadequate Documentation of Conservative Treatment Duration

• Medical necessity requires documented failure of a 6-week trial of nonoperative treatment, which is explicitly missing from this case. 1
• While the patient received steroid injections and radiofrequency ablation with 95% pain reduction, there is no documentation of the duration these treatments were attempted or when they failed. 1
• The fact that injections provided significant relief actually argues against surgical necessity, as the patient responded well to conservative measures. 1

Lack of Functional Impairment Quantification

• Medical necessity requires documented symptoms that significantly impact activities of daily living or sleep, with quantification of functional impairment, which is lacking in this case. 1
• The patient's primary complaint is positional neck pain and stiffness without radicular symptoms, which does not meet criteria for multilevel fusion. 2

---

Specific Technical and Hardware Concerns

Inappropriate Use of Pedicle Screws

• The use of pedicle screws (CPT 22846) in anterior cervical procedures is not standard of care and lacks supporting evidence. 1
• Standard ACDF procedures utilize anterior cervical plates with screws through vertebral bodies, not pedicle screws. 1
• The American Association of Neurological Surgeons recommends anterior cervical plating for multilevel fusions, but this refers to standard anterior plate fixation, not pedicle screw constructs. 3

Excessive and Redundant Grafting Strategy

• The simultaneous use of allograft (20930), autograft (20936), cage (22853), and bone marrow aspirate (20939) represents potentially excessive and redundant grafting strategies. 1
• Evidence demonstrates that single grafting strategies achieve comparable fusion rates without the need for multiple graft types. 1, 4
• For multilevel ACDF, allograft combined with interbody cages achieves fusion rates of 91-95%, which is equivalent to autograft alone. 4
• The addition of iliac crest autograft harvest introduces donor site morbidity (22% persistent hip pain at 1 year) without improving fusion outcomes when allograft and cages are already utilized. 4

Questionable Extent of Fusion

• A C2-C7 fusion (5 levels) for degenerative disc disease without documented myelopathy or progressive neurologic deficits is excessive. 2
• The guidelines recommend ACDF for 1-2 level disease with specific indications; multilevel fusions require stronger justification including cord compression with myelopathy. 2, 3
• The patient's imaging shows disc collapse from C2-C7 with C2-3 and C4-5 most affected, but there is no documentation of cord compression or myelopathy requiring this extensive fusion. 1

---

What Would Be Required for Medical Necessity

Essential Documentation Requirements

• Physical examination documenting objective neurologic deficits: motor weakness, sensory loss, reflex changes, or myelopathic signs (Hoffmann's sign, clonus, gait disturbance). 1, 3
• MRI or CT myelogram demonstrating: cord compression with signal change (myelomalacia), nerve root compression correlating with clinical symptoms, or significant spinal stenosis. 1, 3
• Documentation of conservative treatment duration: specific dates showing at least 6 weeks of failed nonoperative management including physical therapy, medications, and injections. 1
• Functional impairment quantification: validated outcome measures (NDI, VAS scores) documenting significant impact on activities of daily living. 1

Clinical Indications That Would Support Surgery

• Progressive myelopathy with documented cord compression and signal change on MRI. 3
• Radiculopathy with arm pain, weakness, or sensory loss correlating with imaging findings of nerve root compression. 2
• Failed comprehensive conservative management over at least 6 weeks including epidural injections, physical therapy, and medications. 1
• Documented functional impairment affecting work, sleep, or activities of daily living despite conservative treatment. 1

---

Appropriate Surgical Approach When Criteria Are Met

Standard Multilevel ACDF Technique

• For multilevel cervical degenerative disease meeting surgical criteria, ACDF with anterior cervical plating (not pedicle screws) is the standard approach. 3
• Anterior cervical plating reduces pseudarthrosis risk from 4.8% to 0.7% and improves fusion rates from 72% to 91% in multilevel constructs. 3
• The addition of a cervical plate is recommended to reduce the risk of pseudarthrosis and maintain lordosis, particularly critical in multilevel constructs. 2

Optimal Graft Selection

• For multilevel ACDF, either cage with allograft or cage alone achieves fusion rates of 91-98% without requiring multiple graft types. 1, 4
• Titanium or PEEK cages eliminate donor site morbidity while maintaining equivalent clinical outcomes to autograft. 1, 4
• PEEK cages achieve 100% fusion rates at 12 months with 97% good-to-excellent clinical outcomes. 4
• If autograft is used, it should be the sole grafting strategy, not combined with allograft and cage. 4

Alternative to Fusion for Two-Level Disease

• Cervical disc arthroplasty (CDA) is recommended as an alternative to ACDF in selected patients for control of neck and arm pain at 1-2 levels. 2
• For two contiguous levels, CDA demonstrates higher overall success rates (OR 2.710) and lower secondary surgery rates (OR 0.254) compared to ACDF. 5
• CDA preserves motion and reduces adjacent segment degeneration compared to fusion. 6, 5

---

Specific Concerns About Syncope Episodes

Red Flag Requiring Workup Before Surgery

• The patient reports two episodes of syncope (one during sneezing on airplane, one getting out of bed), which require cardiovascular and neurologic evaluation before any cervical surgery. 1
• Syncope with neck manipulation or positional changes could indicate vertebrobasilar insufficiency, which would be a contraindication to extensive cervical fusion without further workup. 1
• These episodes need cardiac evaluation (ECG, Holter monitor, echocardiogram) and neurovascular imaging (CTA or MRA of neck vessels) before proceeding with surgery. 1

---

Recommendation for Peer Review Response

The case should be denied as currently documented and returned to the surgeon with specific requests for:

1. Complete physical examination documenting motor strength (0-5 scale), sensory testing, reflexes, and myelopathic signs at each level. 1
2. Timeline of conservative treatment with specific dates showing at least 6 weeks of failed management. 1
3. MRI report documenting cord compression, signal change, or nerve root compression correlating with symptoms. 1
4. Functional outcome measures (NDI, VAS scores) quantifying disability. 1
5. Cardiovascular and neurovascular workup for syncope episodes before surgical clearance. 1
6. Justification for C2-C7 fusion extent versus more limited fusion at symptomatic levels. 2
7. Rationale for pedicle screws in anterior approach versus standard anterior plating. 1, 3
8. Explanation for multiple graft types when single strategy achieves equivalent outcomes. 1, 4