Is inpatient stay medically necessary for a patient with non-displaced fractures of the thoracic vertebra, without surgical intervention required?

Inpatient Admission Not Medically Necessary for This Patient

For this patient with minor, non-displaced thoracic vertebral compression fractures (T1-T2), no neurological deficit, no need for surgical intervention, and ability to ambulate, same-day discharge is appropriate and inpatient admission is not medically necessary. 1

Clinical Assessment Supporting Outpatient Management

This patient presents with:

• Minor compression fractures at T1-T2 levels with minimal height loss
• Stable fracture pattern - no posterior ligamentous complex injury requiring MRI confirmation
• No neurological deficit - neurologically intact on examination
• No surgical indication - neurosurgery explicitly signed off stating no surgical intervention needed
• No bracing required - indicating fracture stability
• Ambulatory status - patient able to mobilize

1

Evidence-Based Criteria for Conservative Outpatient Management

The American College of Surgeons recommends conservative management for stable fractures (intact posterior ligamentous complex, no neurological deficit, acceptable alignment), which includes NSAIDs, early mobilization, and optional bracing for the first 3 months. 1

Key stability indicators present in this case:

• Intact posterior ligamentous complex (no MRI obtained, but clinical stability evident)
• No spinal cord compression
• Acceptable alignment - minor compression only
• Neurologically intact

1

Appropriate Outpatient Treatment Plan

The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons recommends NSAIDs as first-line analgesia (e.g., ibuprofen 400 mg every 4-6 hours as needed) for pain control in stable vertebral fractures. 1

The American College of Physicians strictly recommends limiting narcotic use due to significant risks including sedation, increased fall risk, decreased physical conditioning, and potential for further injury—particularly dangerous in trauma patients. 1

The American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation encourages early mobilization as tolerated to prevent complications of immobility, including bone density loss (approximately 2% per week), muscle strength loss (1-3% per day), deconditioning, and increased mortality. 1

Critical Pitfalls Avoided by Outpatient Management

The American College of Surgeons advises against prolonged bed rest, as this causes accelerated bone loss, muscle deconditioning, and increased mortality risk. 1

The American Geriatrics Society advises against prolonged bed rest, which accelerates bone loss and causes significant deconditioning. 1

Inpatient admission for observation would expose this patient to:

• Unnecessary immobilization leading to rapid deconditioning
• Increased fall risk from hospital environment
• Nosocomial infection exposure
• Delirium risk from unfamiliar environment
• No therapeutic benefit since no intervention is planned

1

Comparison to Similar Fracture Management

Isolated transverse process fractures are structurally and neurologically stable injuries that do not require spine service intervention or hospitalization. 2 This patient's T11 transverse process fracture component similarly requires no specific intervention.

Most symptomatic vertebral fractures are treated with analgesics, activity modification and bracing on an outpatient basis, with only approximately 10% requiring hospitalization specifically for intractable pain. 3 This patient does not meet criteria for hospitalization based on pain severity.

Appropriate Discharge Plan

The patient should be discharged with:

• NSAIDs for pain control (avoid prolonged narcotics) 1
• Activity modification instructions - avoid heavy lifting, bending, twisting 1
• Early mobilization encouragement - walking as tolerated 1
• Follow-up in 2-4 weeks to assess pain and functional status 1
• Return precautions - worsening pain, new neurological symptoms, inability to ambulate 1

MCG Criteria Misapplication

While MCG lists "vertebral fracture with major injury requiring inpatient care" as an admission criterion, this patient does not have a major injury requiring inpatient care:

• Minor compression fractures explicitly described by consulting neurosurgeon
• No surgical intervention needed
• No bracing required
• No neurological deficit
• Ambulatory and stable

The presence of a vertebral fracture alone does not automatically warrant admission; the severity and stability of the injury determine medical necessity. 1, 2