Diagnosis: Bronchiolitis or Asthma
In pediatric patients presenting with cough and bilateral wheeze, the diagnosis depends critically on age and wheezing history: children under 2 years with their first wheezing episode most likely have viral bronchiolitis (typically RSV or rhinovirus), while recurrent wheezers or those over 2 years should be evaluated for asthma—but asthma should never be diagnosed on symptoms alone. 1, 2
Age-Based Diagnostic Approach
Children Under 12 Months (First Episode)
- Bronchiolitis is the most likely diagnosis, characterized by tachypnea, wheeze, cough, and crackles following an upper respiratory illness 2
- RSV accounts for approximately 70% of cases, followed by rhinovirus, with viral detection rates reaching 93% 2, 3
- The inflammation causes edema, increased mucus production, and necrosis of epithelial cells in small airways (≤2 mm diameter), producing the characteristic wheeze 2
Children 12-24 Months
- This age group presents the greatest diagnostic challenge with significant overlap between bronchiolitis and early asthma 4
- First-time wheezers should be diagnosed with bronchiolitis, not asthma 3
- Recurrent wheezers in this age range require careful evaluation, as rhinovirus infections and atopic characteristics increase significantly with age and number of previous episodes 3
- Diagnosis patterns vary widely between institutions, with asthma diagnoses increasing from 2% at 3 months to 44% at 23 months of age 4
Children Over 2 Years
- Recurrent episodes of "bronchiolitis" after the first year of life likely represent recurrent wheezing or asthma, not viral bronchiolitis 5
- However, asthma cannot be diagnosed based on cough and wheeze alone—objective testing is required 1
Critical Diagnostic Distinctions
When to Consider Bronchiolitis
- Age under 2 years, particularly under 12 months 2
- First wheezing episode 3
- Preceding upper respiratory symptoms 2
- Presence of crackles/crepitations on examination 2
- Wet/productive cough quality 1
When to Consider Asthma
- Recurrent wheeze is the most important symptom of asthma, not cough 1, 6
- History of multiple previous wheezing episodes 3
- Age over 2 years with recurrent symptoms 5
- Evidence of atopy (eczema, allergic sensitization) 3
- Requires objective confirmation with spirometry (when age-appropriate, typically >6 years) showing reversible airflow obstruction 1, 6
Common Diagnostic Pitfalls to Avoid
Do NOT Diagnose Asthma Based on Symptoms Alone
- The European Respiratory Society strongly recommends against diagnosing asthma based on symptoms alone 1
- Children with chronic cough (>4 weeks) as the only symptom are unlikely to have asthma 1, 6
- Only about 25% of children with cough, wheeze, and exercise-induced symptoms actually have asthma 1
- The sensitivity and specificity of cough as a marker for wheeze in asthma is poor (34% and 35%, respectively) 1
Recognize "Specific Cough" Pointers
- Wet/productive cough suggests protracted bacterial bronchitis, not asthma 1
- Presence of specific cough characteristics requires investigation for underlying disease (bronchiectasis, foreign body, aspiration, cardiac anomalies) 1
- Normal chest X-ray and spirometry are essential to rule out serious pathology 1
Viral Etiology Matters
- RSV-bronchiolitis presents in younger infants with mechanical airway obstruction from mucus and debris 7
- Rhinovirus-induced wheezing is associated with atopic predisposition and higher risk of subsequent asthma development 7, 3
- Rhinovirus infections increase significantly with age and are more common in recurrent wheezers 3
Risk Factors for Severe Disease (Bronchiolitis)
- Age <12 weeks 2, 5
- History of prematurity (especially <32 weeks gestation) 2, 5
- Underlying cardiopulmonary disease 2, 5
- Immunodeficiency 2, 5
Management Implications
For Bronchiolitis
- Supportive care is the mainstay (nasal suctioning, positioning, hydration) 5
- Do NOT use asthma medications (bronchodilators or corticosteroids) unless there is other evidence of asthma 6, 5
- Most cases are self-limited, with 90% of children cough-free by 21 days 5
For Suspected Asthma
- Perform objective testing before initiating treatment: spirometry with bronchodilator response when age-appropriate 6
- Chest radiograph to exclude other pathology 6
- Assessment for true asthma symptoms (recurrent wheeze and/or dyspnea, not just cough) 6
- There is no evidence to support β2-agonists in children with acute cough and no evidence of airflow obstruction 6