Can a patient with Chronic Kidney Disease (CKD) take an elderberry supplement?

Elderberry Supplementation in CKD: Not Recommended

Patients with CKD should avoid elderberry supplements due to lack of safety data, potential for herb-drug interactions, and the general principle that herbal products not proven beneficial should be avoided in this vulnerable population.

Why Elderberry Should Be Avoided in CKD

Absence of Evidence for Safety or Benefit

• The KDOQI 2020 guidelines do not specifically address elderberry, but they establish a clear framework: supplements should only be used when there is documented deficiency or proven clinical benefit 1.
• Elderberry is not among the vitamins or supplements recommended for routine use in CKD patients at any stage 1.
• The National Kidney Foundation identified 37 herbs as potentially harmful in CKD, and while elderberry may not be explicitly listed, the broader concern is that 8% of US adults use potentially harmful supplements, with CKD patients showing similar usage rates despite increased vulnerability 2.

High Risk of Herb-Drug Interactions

• CKD patients typically take multiple medications (antihypertensives, immunosuppressants post-transplant, anticoagulants), creating substantial risk for herb-drug interactions 3.
• Over 60% of websites selling herbal supplements for kidney disease fail to advise consulting a physician, and >90% do not mention potential drug interactions 4.
• In one study of CKD patients using herbal supplements, ginseng alone had 18 possible drug interactions, with 6 being severe interactions with anticoagulants 3.

Lack of Human Studies in CKD

• Systematic evaluation of herbal supplements marketed for kidney disease found that claimed benefits were not adequately studied in humans, and available animal studies showed detrimental effects 4.
• Even cranberry, which has more research than elderberry, showed no benefit in reducing uremic toxins or LPS levels in a randomized controlled trial of non-dialysis CKD patients 5.

KDOQI Framework for Supplement Use in CKD

What IS Recommended

The 2020 KDOQI guidelines provide clear direction on appropriate supplementation 1:

• Water-soluble vitamins and essential trace elements for CKD 5D patients with inadequate dietary intake 1
• Vitamin C supplementation only to meet RDA (90 mg/d men, 75 mg/d women) when deficiency risk exists 1
• Vitamin D (cholecalciferol or ergocalciferol) for documented deficiency 1
• Folate/B12 only for documented deficiency with clinical signs 1

What Is NOT Recommended

• Vitamin A and E should NOT be routinely supplemented in CKD 5D due to accumulation and toxicity risk 1
• Selenium and zinc should NOT be routinely supplemented (Grade 2C recommendation) 1
• Vitamin K supplements should NOT be given to patients on warfarin 1

Clinical Approach to Herbal Supplements in CKD

Step 1: Assess Actual Nutritional Needs

• A registered dietitian should assess dietary vitamin intake periodically 1.
• Supplementation should only be considered for individuals with inadequate vitamin intake 1.
• The goal is to meet the RDA for adequate intake through diet first 1.

Step 2: Avoid Unproven Herbal Products

• Elderberry falls into the category of herbal supplements without proven benefit in CKD 2, 4.
• The principle established by KDOQI is clear: do not supplement unless there is evidence of deficiency or proven clinical benefit 1.

Step 3: Consider Safer Alternatives

• If the patient is seeking immune support or antioxidant benefits (common reasons for elderberry use), focus instead on 1:
  • Increasing dietary intake of fruits and vegetables (recommended for CKD 1-4 to reduce net acid production) 1
  • Ensuring adequate intake of evidence-based vitamins (C, D, B-complex) if deficient 1

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

Don't Assume "Natural" Means Safe

• Health care providers must actively discuss supplement use with CKD patients, as many use herbal products without medical guidance 2, 3.
• The prevalence of potentially harmful supplement use is similar in CKD patients compared to those without CKD (approximately 8%), indicating lack of awareness of risks 2.

Don't Overlook Drug Interactions

• Always review the patient's complete medication list before any supplement is considered 3.
• Pay particular attention to anticoagulants, immunosuppressants (in transplant patients), and antihypertensives 3.

Don't Rely on Internet Information

• Internet sources for herbal supplements in kidney disease are unreliable, with most failing to mention contraindications, drug interactions, or the need for physician consultation 4.
• Animal studies of herbs marketed for kidney disease often show detrimental rather than beneficial effects 4.