Is L5-S1 Transforaminal Lumbar Interbody Fusion (TLIF) medically necessary for a 32-year-old male with severe lumbar spinal stenosis, large disc protrusion, and significant degenerative instability at the L5-S1 level, who has stopped smoking and is experiencing severe left-sided low back pain, numbness, and tingling in bilateral legs and feet, despite taking Lyrica (pregabalin) with minimal relief and THC (tetrahydrocannabinol) with adequate relief?

Medical Necessity Determination: L5-S1 TLIF NOT APPROVED - Critical Deficiencies in Documentation

This L5-S1 TLIF procedure does NOT meet medical necessity criteria due to two critical deficiencies: (1) absence of laboratory-confirmed nicotine cessation despite recent smoking history, and (2) lack of documented formal physical therapy, without clear evidence that waiver criteria are met.

Primary Deficiency Analysis

Nicotine Cessation Documentation - NOT MET

• The CPB 0743 policy explicitly requires nicotine-free status for at least 6 weeks prior to surgery, with laboratory confirmation (blood/urine nicotine ≤10 ng/ml or urinary cotinine ≤10 ng/ml) for patients with recent nicotine use within the past year 1
• This patient reports stopping smoking on [DATE], but no lab report is provided—only surgeon summary stating "stopped smoking" 1
• The policy allows waiver of nicotine testing only for urgent indications including myelopathy, cauda equina syndrome, severe weakness (MRC grade 4- or less), progressive weakness, or associated infection/tumor/fracture 1
• This patient does NOT meet waiver criteria: Clinical exam shows 4/5 bilateral EHL strength (not severe weakness by MRC standards), no myelopathy, no cauda equina syndrome, no progressive weakness documented, and no infection/tumor/fracture 1, 2

Formal Physical Therapy Documentation - NOT MET

• CPB 0743 Section I.C.D. requires at least 6 weeks of conservative therapy including formal physical therapy before lumbar fusion can be considered medically necessary 1, 2
• The clinical documentation states only "Taking Lyrica with minimal relief of pain, THC with adequate relief" on [DATE]—no formal supervised physical therapy is documented 1
• The waiver provision for conservative therapy applies only to "severe stenosis associated with instability (dynamic excursion with flexion/extension or from supine to standing) when fusion is requested" 1
• While this patient has severe stenosis and retrolisthesis (7mm at L5-S1), there is NO documentation of dynamic instability on flexion-extension radiographs or supine-to-standing films 1, 2

Clinical Criteria Assessment (Otherwise Met)

Imaging and Structural Pathology - MET

• MRI demonstrates large left paracentral and foraminal disc protrusion with severe left lateral recess and left foraminal stenosis at L5-S1, with endplate degenerative changes and marrow edema 1
• CT confirms large L5-S1 disc herniation with central canal and left neural foraminal stenosis 1
• X-ray shows 7mm retrolisthesis at L5-S1, which constitutes "any degree of spondylolisthesis" meeting CPB criteria for fusion when combined with decompression 1, 2, 3

Clinical Presentation - MET

• Patient demonstrates signs of neural compression: bilateral lower extremity numbness/tingling, neurogenic claudication (pain increases with walking, decreases with rest), positive bilateral straight leg raise, 4/5 bilateral EHL weakness 1, 3
• Pain severity 9/10 with movement significantly limits activities of daily living (bending, sitting, standing) 1
• Symptoms correlate anatomically with imaging findings at L5-S1 level 1, 2

Fusion Indication - MET (If Other Criteria Satisfied)

• The combination of severe stenosis with retrolisthesis (any grade spondylolisthesis) meets CPB 0743 Section I.9.b criteria for fusion in addition to decompression 1, 2, 3
• American Association of Neurological Surgeons guidelines support fusion when decompression coincides with any degree of spondylolisthesis, as retrolisthesis constitutes documented instability 2, 3
• Class II evidence demonstrates 96% good/excellent outcomes with decompression plus fusion versus only 44% with decompression alone in patients with stenosis and spondylolisthesis 2, 3

Evidence-Based Rationale for Denial

Why Nicotine Testing Cannot Be Waived

• Nicotine significantly impairs bone healing and fusion rates—the 6-week nicotine-free requirement is evidence-based to optimize surgical outcomes 1
• The patient's self-report of smoking cessation on [DATE] is insufficient without laboratory confirmation, as studies demonstrate poor correlation between patient-reported and laboratory-confirmed nicotine status 1
• The clinical presentation does NOT meet urgent/emergent criteria that would justify waiving nicotine testing: 4/5 strength is not severe weakness (MRC 4- or less), symptoms are chronic rather than acute/progressive, and no cauda equina or myelopathy is present 1, 2

Why Physical Therapy Cannot Be Waived Without Dynamic Instability

• The CPB policy allows waiver of conservative therapy only for "severe stenosis associated with instability (dynamic excursion with flexion/extension or from supine to standing)" 1
• Static retrolisthesis on plain radiographs does NOT constitute dynamic instability—flexion-extension films or supine-to-standing comparison films are required to document dynamic excursion 1, 2
• American Association of Neurological Surgeons guidelines emphasize that comprehensive conservative management including formal physical therapy must be attempted for at least 6 weeks to 3 months before fusion 1, 2
• The patient's adequate relief with THC suggests conservative measures may provide benefit, further supporting the need for formal physical therapy trial 1

Requirements for Approval

Mandatory Documentation Needed

1. Laboratory confirmation of nicotine cessation: Blood/urine nicotine level ≤10 ng/ml OR urinary cotinine ≤10 ng/ml, drawn within 6 weeks prior to proposed surgery date 1

2. Either:

   • Documentation of at least 6 weeks of formal supervised physical therapy with objective records showing inadequate response 1, 2
   • OR flexion-extension radiographs or supine-to-standing films demonstrating dynamic instability (>3-4mm translation or >10-15 degrees angular motion) to justify waiver of physical therapy requirement 1, 2

Alternative Pathway if Urgent Criteria Develop

• If patient develops progressive neurological deficit (worsening from 4/5 to 3/5 or worse EHL strength), cauda equina symptoms, or other urgent indications, both nicotine testing and physical therapy requirements could be waived 1
• Current clinical status does NOT meet these urgent criteria 1, 2

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not confuse static retrolisthesis with dynamic instability—the latter requires motion studies 1, 2
• Do not accept surgeon attestation of smoking cessation without laboratory confirmation when patient has smoked within the past year 1
• Do not waive physical therapy requirement based solely on severity of stenosis—dynamic instability must be documented 1
• Recognize that while the surgical indication itself is appropriate (severe stenosis with spondylolisthesis), preoperative optimization requirements exist to maximize fusion success and minimize complications 1, 2

Expected Outcomes if Criteria Met

• TLIF provides fusion rates of 92-95% when performed in appropriately selected patients who meet all preoperative criteria 1, 4
• Patients with stenosis and spondylolisthesis achieve significant improvements in pain and function when fusion is added to decompression, with 93-96% reporting good/excellent outcomes 2, 3
• However, these outcomes are predicated on proper patient selection including nicotine-free status and failed conservative management 1, 2

---

DETERMINATION: DENY pending submission of (1) laboratory-confirmed nicotine cessation and (2) either formal physical therapy documentation OR dynamic instability films justifying therapy waiver.