What are the differential diagnoses for a patient presenting with symptoms of acute cholecystitis, likely caused by gallstones, and experiencing right upper quadrant abdominal pain, fever, and leukocytosis?

Differential Diagnoses for Acute Cholecystitis

When a patient presents with right upper quadrant pain, fever, and leukocytosis suggestive of acute cholecystitis, you must systematically exclude several conditions that mimic this presentation, including chronic cholecystitis, peptic ulcer disease, acute pancreatitis, gastroenteritis, ascending cholangitis, and bowel obstruction. 1

Primary Biliary Differentials

Chronic Cholecystitis

• Presents with recurrent right upper quadrant pain but typically lacks fever and leukocytosis that characterize acute cholecystitis 1
• The gallbladder may appear contracted or distended on imaging, with pericholecystic fluid usually absent 1
• Diagnosis is difficult on anatomic imaging alone; clinical context and chronicity of symptoms are key distinguishing features 1

Ascending Cholangitis

• Distinguished from acute cholecystitis by the presence of jaundice indicating biliary obstruction 2
• Murphy's sign is typically absent in cholangitis, whereas it may be present in cholecystitis 2
• Right upper quadrant tenderness, fever, and pain are common to both conditions, making jaundice the critical differentiating feature 2
• Initial ultrasound should assess for biliary dilatation; MRCP may be necessary for detailed visualization of bile duct obstruction 2

Biliary Dyskinesia

• Presents with recurrent right upper quadrant pain mimicking chronic cholecystitis 1
• Diagnosed using cholecystokinin-augmented hepatobiliary scintigraphy with calculation of gallbladder ejection fraction 1
• This test is less useful in patients with atypical symptoms 1

Gastrointestinal Differentials

Peptic Ulcer Disease

• Can present with epigastric or right upper quadrant pain 1
• Typically lacks fever and leukocytosis unless complicated by perforation 1
• Pain pattern often relates to meals differently than biliary colic
• Ultrasound can help exclude biliary pathology while identifying alternative diagnoses 1

Acute Pancreatitis

• Presents with epigastric pain that may radiate to the right upper quadrant 1
• Elevated serum lipase and amylase distinguish pancreatitis from cholecystitis
• Ultrasound evaluation should assess the pancreas and identify gallstones as a potential etiology 1
• CT with IV contrast may be needed to evaluate for pancreatic complications 1

Gastroenteritis

• Can cause right upper quadrant discomfort but typically presents with prominent diarrhea and vomiting 1
• Fever may be present but is usually lower grade than in acute cholecystitis
• Lacks the focal right upper quadrant tenderness and positive Murphy's sign characteristic of cholecystitis 1

Bowel Obstruction

• May cause right upper quadrant pain if the obstruction involves proximal small bowel 1
• Distinguished by distension, absence of bowel sounds, and characteristic imaging findings of dilated bowel loops
• CT is superior to ultrasound for identifying the level and cause of obstruction 1

Hepatic Differentials

Hepatic Abscess

• Presents with fever, right upper quadrant pain, and leukocytosis similar to cholecystitis 3
• Ultrasound can identify hepatic lesions, but CT with IV contrast is superior for characterizing abscesses and identifying complications 1
• Clinical history of recent bacteremia, diverticulitis, or biliary instrumentation may suggest this diagnosis 3

Acute Hepatitis

• Causes right upper quadrant pain and may present with fever 3
• Distinguished by marked transaminase elevation (typically >500 U/L) rather than the mild elevation seen in cholecystitis
• Ultrasound can assess for cirrhosis with sensitivity of 65-95% and positive predictive value of 98% 4

Renal and Adrenal Differentials

Pyelonephritis

• Right-sided pyelonephritis can cause right upper quadrant pain and fever 3
• Distinguished by urinary symptoms, costovertebral angle tenderness, and pyuria on urinalysis
• Ultrasound can evaluate for hydronephrosis and renal parenchymal abnormalities 3

Nephrolithiasis

• Right renal colic may be perceived as right upper quadrant pain 3
• Typically presents with colicky pain radiating to the groin and hematuria
• Ultrasound can identify hydronephrosis; CT without contrast is the gold standard for stone detection 3

Thoracic Causes

Right Lower Lobe Pneumonia

• Can cause referred right upper quadrant pain, fever, and leukocytosis 3
• Distinguished by respiratory symptoms, abnormal lung auscultation, and chest radiograph findings
• Ultrasound may incidentally identify pleural effusion 3

Diagnostic Algorithm

Start with right upper quadrant ultrasound as the initial imaging modality, which has 96% accuracy for detecting gallstones and can identify alternative diagnoses 1

• If ultrasound confirms acute cholecystitis (gallstones, gallbladder wall thickening >3mm, pericholecystic fluid, positive sonographic Murphy's sign), proceed to surgical consultation 1
• If ultrasound is negative or equivocal and clinical suspicion remains high, order hepatobiliary scintigraphy (HIDA scan), which has 97% sensitivity and 90% specificity for acute cholecystitis 1
• If ultrasound suggests biliary obstruction with dilated common bile duct, order MRCP to evaluate for choledocholithiasis or cholangitis, which has 85-100% sensitivity and 90% specificity 4
• If ultrasound is negative and there is no alternative diagnosis, order CT with IV contrast to evaluate for complications or alternative pathology 1

Critical Pitfalls to Avoid

• Do not rely on Murphy's sign alone: it has a positive likelihood ratio of only 2.8 and may be absent after pain medication administration 5
• Acalculous cholecystitis (5-10% of cases) occurs in critically ill patients without gallstones; HIDA scan is the diagnostic test of choice 6
• Atypical presentations occur: acute cholecystitis may present without fever, leukocytosis, or classic right upper quadrant pain 7
• In critically ill patients, gallbladder abnormalities on ultrasound are common even without acute cholecystitis, limiting diagnostic specificity 1
• CT may miss gallstones since up to 80% are noncalcified and radiolucent 4